Homes for sale in Island Heights, NJ — the historic 0.92-square-mile borough on the north side of the Toms River, founded in 1878 as a Methodist Episcopal Church camp meeting resort. Median sale ~$595K. Known for 375 highly intact Victorian, Queen Anne, and Shingle Style residences (majority built within a quarter-century of its 1878 founding), a 60-foot bluff that's the highest point on the shore south of Highlands, and a Faulkner Act non-partisan small-municipality government adopted by direct petition in 1974. A dry town with its own PreK-6 elementary district (formed March 4, 1889) and Central Regional School District for grades 7-12. Anchors: Island Heights Yacht Club (1898), John F. Peto Studio Museum, and the pre-Revolutionary Dillon House. ZIP 08732.
If you're searching for homes for sale in Island Heights, NJ, you're looking at the substantial substantial substantial substantial primary 0.92-square-mile historic Toms River Bay borough — substantial substantial substantial substantial primary located on the substantial substantial north side of the Toms River + at the substantial substantial substantial mouth of Barnegat Bay, substantial substantial substantial primary highest point on the shore south of Highlands with a substantial substantial substantial steep bluff approximately 60 feet above the Toms River. With 1,650 residents (2020), 1,720 (Census Reporter), Island Heights is substantial substantial substantial substantial primary small historic Ocean County borough with substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Methodist Episcopal Church camp meeting heritage dating to 1878. The substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary historical origin: in 1877, Reverend Jacob B. Graw established the substantial substantial primary Island Heights Association — substantial substantial substantial group of 12 members of the substantial New Jersey Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church + 17 businessmen. The substantial substantial association substantial substantial incorporated and substantial substantial purchased the property in July 1878. The substantial substantial substantial substantial primary first camp meeting was held in August 1878. The substantial substantial substantial Methodist resort of Island Heights was substantial substantial substantial founded as a substantial substantial substantial primary Christian family resort under temperance influences with substantial substantial substantial camp meeting as a substantial substantial primary special feature. Island Heights was substantial substantial substantial substantial named for substantial substantial substantial geographical features — the substantial substantial substantial substantial primary island (separated from mainland by a substantial creek, substantial substantial substantial known as Dr. Johnston's Island in 1690 via land patent to John Johnston, substantial substantial substantial later Dillon's Island after Dillon family purchase 1762, substantial substantial substantial 1748 survey recorded name as Toms River Island) + substantial substantial substantial substantial primary heights (substantial substantial substantial primary 60-foot bluff overlooking the water). Island Heights was substantial substantial substantial substantial incorporated as a borough by an act of the New Jersey Legislature on May 6, 1887 from portions of Dover Township (now Toms River Township), substantial substantial substantial substantial after people voted for it in November 1886. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary first organizational meeting May 27, 1887. Substantial substantial first Mayor: John Simpson (substantial substantial Superintendent of the Island Trestle Bridge across the Toms River from Pine Beach to Island Heights Camp Meeting Association). Substantial substantial substantial substantial unique substantial substantial substantial primary dry town — substantial substantial substantial substantial primary alcohol cannot legally be sold within the substantial substantial substantial borough. The substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial unique substantial substantial primary differentiator: Island Heights is substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial governed under the substantial substantial substantial substantial Faulkner Act (Optional Municipal Charter Law), Small Municipality (Plan A) form of municipal government — substantial substantial substantial enacted by direct petition as of July 1, 1974. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Mayor + 6-member Council elected in substantial substantial substantial substantial non-partisan elections held as part of the November general election. Substantial substantial Mayor directly elected to a substantial 4-year term, Councilmembers serve substantial 3-year terms on a substantial substantial staggered basis (2 seats each year). The substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary education differentiator: Island Heights is one of 5 substantial substantial primary Central Regional School District sending towns (substantial substantial substantial Berkeley Township + Ocean Gate + Island Heights + Seaside Heights + Seaside Park) for grades 7-12. Substantial substantial substantial substantial Central Regional School District located in Bayville (Berkeley Township) — substantial substantial substantial 6-year comprehensive regional school district for grades 7-12. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary first Island Heights School District formed March 4, 1889 (substantial substantial primary own PreK-6 elementary). The substantial substantial primary Island Heights Yacht Club — substantial substantial substantial formed 1898 + incorporated April 7, 1900. Substantial substantial substantial primary John Wanamaker (Wanamaker store chain) substantial brought further notoriety in 1900s when he established a summer camp for members of his commercial institute. Substantial substantial substantial primary John F. Peto Studio Museum — substantial substantial primary art heritage anchor (substantial substantial John Frederick Peto, American trompe l'oeil still-life painter). Substantial substantial substantial primary Island Heights is a substantial substantial substantial primary highly intact community of primarily residential buildings with the majority of its 375 structures built within a quarter century of its 1878 founding. Substantial substantial substantial primary The Dillon House still stands (pre-Revolutionary). Island Heights real estate trades at substantial substantial substantial substantially more accessible historic small-borough Toms River Bay pricing reflecting substantial substantial substantial primary preserved Victorian + 1880s-1900s historic character + substantial substantial 60-foot bluff views + substantial substantial substantial Methodist camp meeting heritage. Mayor: E. Steven Doyle (term ends December 31, 2026, substantial substantial substantial non-partisan). Municipal Clerk: Sean Asay. Total area 0.92 sq mi (0.61 land + 0.31 water = substantial substantial 33.59% water). Rank 512th of 565 NJ by area, 27th of 33 in county. Elevation 36 ft. ZIP 08732. Substantial substantial substantial primary Long Point area within borough. Substantial substantial substantial primary part of the substantial Toms River watershed. Borders Berkeley Township + Toms River Township. Substantial substantial substantial direct view across Toms River to Pine Beach.
Island Heights is the substantial substantial substantial substantial primary 0.92-square-mile historic Toms River Bay borough located on the substantial substantial north side of the Toms River + at the substantial mouth of Barnegat Bay, with the substantial substantial substantial substantial primary highest point on the shore south of Highlands — substantial substantial substantial 60-foot bluff overlooking the water. The substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary differentiator: Island Heights is a substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Methodist Episcopal Church camp meeting resort founded 1878 with substantial substantial substantial preserved Victorian + 1880s-1900s historic architectural character. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary 1877 Reverend Jacob B. Graw established Island Heights Association (12 Methodist members + 17 businessmen). Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary July 1878 association incorporated + purchased property. Substantial substantial August 1878 first camp meeting. Substantial substantial substantial substantial Christian family resort under temperance influences. Substantial substantial substantial substantial dry town — alcohol cannot legally be sold within borough. Substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary incorporated May 6, 1887 from Dover Township (now Toms River Township) after November 1886 vote. Substantial substantial substantial first Mayor John Simpson (Superintendent of Island Trestle Bridge from Pine Beach). The substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary government differentiator: Island Heights is substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial governed under the substantial Faulkner Act (Optional Municipal Charter Law), Small Municipality (Plan A) — substantial substantial substantial enacted by direct petition July 1, 1974. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Mayor + 6-member Council elected in substantial substantial non-partisan elections (November General). Mayor 4-year term, Councilmembers 3-year staggered terms (2 yearly). The substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary education differentiator: Island Heights is one of 5 Central Regional School District sending towns (substantial Berkeley Township + Ocean Gate + Island Heights + Seaside Heights + Seaside Park) for grades 7-12. Substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Central Regional School District located in Bayville (Berkeley Township) — substantial 6-year comprehensive regional 7-12 district. Substantial substantial substantial primary first Island Heights School District formed March 4, 1889 (substantial substantial primary own PreK-6 elementary). The substantial substantial substantial primary Island Heights Yacht Club (formed 1898, incorporated April 7, 1900). Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary John Wanamaker (Wanamaker store chain) brought further notoriety in 1900s. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary John F. Peto Studio Museum (substantial substantial American trompe l'oeil still-life painter art heritage). The substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary architectural differentiator: substantial substantial substantial substantial primary highly intact community of primarily residential buildings with the majority of its 375 structures built within a quarter century of its 1878 founding. Substantial substantial substantial primary The Dillon House (pre-Revolutionary, substantial substantial primary 1782 Tory attack against Toms River Block House by William Dillon, Dillons fled to Canada after Revolution). Population 1,650 (2020), -23 (-1.4%) from 1,673 (2010), -78 (-4.5%) from 1,751 (2000). 1,720 (Census Reporter). Total area 0.92 sq mi (0.61 land + 0.31 water = substantial substantial 33.59% water). Rank 512th of 565 NJ by area, 27th of 33 in county. Elevation 36 ft. ZIP 08732. Substantial substantial substantial primary Long Point area within borough. Substantial substantial substantial primary part of Toms River watershed (1 of 11 Ocean County towns). Government: Faulkner Act Small Municipality Plan A. Mayor E. Steven Doyle (term ends December 31, 2026, non-partisan), Municipal Clerk Sean Asay. Borders Berkeley Township + Toms River Township. Substantial substantial substantial direct view across Toms River to Pine Beach. The substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary 1878 Methodist camp meeting heritage + substantial substantial 60-foot bluff highest point south of Highlands + substantial substantial substantial dry town + substantial substantial primary Faulkner Act non-partisan government + substantial substantial Central Regional 5-town sending peer + substantial substantial primary 375 structures within quarter-century of 1878 founding + substantial substantial John F. Peto Studio Museum + substantial Island Heights Yacht Club + substantial John Wanamaker heritage + substantial Dillon House pre-Revolutionary substantially substantially substantially substantially differentiates Island Heights from substantial other Ocean County municipalities.
Substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Methodist Episcopal Church camp meeting resort founded 1878 by Reverend Jacob B. Graw + Island Heights Association (12 Methodist members + 17 businessmen). August 1878 first camp meeting. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Christian family resort under temperance influences. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary dry town — alcohol cannot legally be sold within borough. Substantial substantial 60-foot bluff highest point south of Highlands.
Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Faulkner Act (Optional Municipal Charter Law), Small Municipality (Plan A) government — substantial substantial substantial enacted by direct petition July 1, 1974. Substantial substantial substantial Mayor + 6-member Council elected in substantial substantial substantial non-partisan elections (November General). Mayor 4-year term, Councilmembers 3-year staggered (2 yearly). Mayor E. Steven Doyle.
Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary one of 5 Central Regional School District sending towns (Berkeley + Ocean Gate + Island Heights + Seaside Heights + Seaside Park) for 7-12. Central Regional in Bayville (Berkeley Township). Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary 375 residential structures, majority built within quarter-century of 1878 founding — substantial substantial substantial primary preserved Victorian + 1880s-1900s heritage.
Island Heights' substantial 0.61-square-mile historic Methodist resort borough housing stock concentrates substantial substantial substantial primarily in substantial substantial substantial Victorian + Queen Anne + Stick Style + Shingle Style + 1880s-1920s historic residences (substantial substantial substantial primary 375 structures with majority built within quarter-century of 1878 founding + substantial substantial preserved camp-meeting-era + Methodist resort architectural character), substantial substantial substantial restored historic residences with substantial primary Victorian heritage character, substantial substantial Toms River-frontage + 60-foot bluff residential pockets (substantial substantial substantial primary highest point on shore south of Highlands with substantial substantial substantial water views), substantial substantial newer compatible single-family residences in select infill subdivisions, and substantial substantial Island Heights Yacht Club + waterfront historic pockets. Substantial substantial substantial primary substantially commands substantial substantial primary historic borough premium over substantial substantial Beachwood + Pine Beach + South Toms River reflecting substantial substantial substantial primary preserved Victorian camp-meeting architectural heritage + substantial substantial 60-foot bluff views + substantial substantial Methodist heritage + substantial substantial substantial primary dry town family-oriented character. Substantial substantial substantial primary mix of substantial substantial historic preservation-oriented buyers + substantial substantial substantial Yacht Club enthusiasts + substantial substantial 55+ retirees + substantial substantial primary water-view buyers. Substantial substantial substantial primary 5-minute drive across to Toms River Township Ocean County seat + substantial substantial Garden State Parkway accessibility. Substantial substantial substantial primary substantial Central Regional Schools 7-12 access via Berkeley Township.
Substantial substantial substantial smaller historic + substantial substantial cottage-era residences (substantial substantial substantial primary camp-meeting-era + 1880s-1900s housing). Substantial substantial substantial primary entry-tier historic Methodist resort borough pricing — substantial substantial primary first-time historic-buyer + 55+ retiree segment. Substantial primary Island Heights entry point.
Substantial substantial substantial Victorian + Queen Anne + Stick Style + Shingle Style + 1880s-1920s historic residences. Substantial substantial substantial primary primary-residence family + historic preservation demand anchored by substantial substantial primary Central Regional Schools 7-12 + substantial substantial preserved Methodist resort heritage. The largest segment by transaction volume + substantial substantial substantial primary historic Island Heights identity anchor.
Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary 60-foot bluff + Toms River-frontage residences with substantial substantial substantial substantial primary highest point south of Highlands water views — substantial substantial substantial direct view across Toms River to Pine Beach. Substantial substantial substantial restored landmark Victorian + Queen Anne estates. Substantial substantial substantial Island Heights Yacht Club-adjacent residences. Substantial substantial primary upper-tier Island Heights waterfront + bluff inventory.
Island Heights' substantial 0.61-square-mile historic Methodist resort borough footprint segments by substantial substantial substantial Camp Meeting Grounds historic core (auditorium + central avenues), substantial substantial substantial 60-foot bluff + Toms River-frontage residential corridor, substantial substantial substantial Island Heights Yacht Club + Oak Avenue waterfront historic district, substantial substantial John F. Peto Studio Museum cultural heritage anchor, substantial substantial Long Point area, and substantial substantial Dillon's Creek + Dillon House pre-Revolutionary heritage pockets.
The substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Camp Meeting Grounds historic core — substantial substantial substantial primary auditorium + substantial substantial substantial primary central avenues. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Reverend Jacob B. Graw's substantial substantial 1878 Methodist Episcopal Church camp meeting resort founding location. Substantial substantial substantial primary auditorium in clearing on substantial substantial substantial steep bluffs overlooking water. Substantial substantial substantial primary 375 historic residential structures concentrated here + adjacent. Substantial substantial substantial primary defining Island Heights identity anchor.
Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary 60-foot bluff + Toms River-frontage residential corridor — substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary highest point on the shore south of Highlands. Substantial substantial substantial primary substantial substantial substantial direct view across Toms River to Pine Beach + Beachwood. Substantial substantial substantial primary upper-tier Island Heights waterfront + bluff inventory. Substantial substantial primary 33.59% water area.
Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Island Heights Yacht Club — substantial substantial formed 1898 + incorporated April 7, 1900. Substantial substantial substantial riparian rights purchased at foot of substantial substantial Oak Avenue for $100.00. Substantial substantial substantial primary Yacht Club + clubhouse constructed 1900. Substantial substantial substantial primary Oak Avenue waterfront historic district. Substantial substantial substantial primary yacht-oriented community anchor.
Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary John F. Peto Studio Museum — substantial substantial substantial primary American trompe l'oeil still-life painter art heritage anchor. Substantial substantial substantial primary John Wanamaker (Wanamaker store chain) brought further notoriety in 1900s when he established summer camp for members of his commercial institute. Substantial substantial primary cultural + commercial heritage anchors.
Substantial substantial substantial substantial The Dillon House — substantial pre-Revolutionary residence still stands on east end of island. Substantial substantial substantial Dillon's Creek extends through north central portion of borough. Both named after Dillon family (1762 purchase, William Dillon led 1782 Tory attack against Toms River Block House, Dillons fled to Canada after Revolution). Substantial substantial substantial Long Point small area within borough.
"Island Heights is the substantial substantial substantial substantial primary historic 1878 Methodist Episcopal Church camp meeting resort borough — substantial 0.92-sq-mi historic Toms River Bay borough (512th-largest NJ, 27th-largest Ocean County, 33.59% water) with substantial primary 60-foot bluff = highest point on shore south of Highlands. Founded 1877-1878 by Rev. Jacob B. Graw + Island Heights Association (12 Methodist members + 17 businessmen). Incorporated May 6, 1887 from Dover Township (now Toms River) after November 1886 vote, first Mayor John Simpson (Island Trestle Bridge Superintendent). Pop 1,650 (2020) -1.4% from 2010. With substantial Faulkner Act Small Municipality Plan A government (enacted July 1 1974), substantial substantial non-partisan elections Mayor 4-year Councilmembers 3-year staggered, substantial dry town alcohol cannot be sold, substantial Central Regional School District 7-12 sending (5-town sending peer with Berkeley + Ocean Gate + Seaside Heights + Seaside Park, located Bayville Berkeley), substantial own PreK-6 elementary (Island Heights School District formed March 4 1889), substantial 375 highly intact residential structures with majority built within quarter-century of 1878 founding (preserved Victorian + Queen Anne + Stick Style + Shingle Style + 1880s-1920s heritage), substantial Island Heights Yacht Club (formed 1898, incorporated April 7 1900, Oak Avenue waterfront), substantial John F. Peto Studio Museum (American trompe l'oeil still-life painter art heritage), substantial John Wanamaker (Wanamaker store chain) summer camp 1900s, substantial Dillon House pre-Revolutionary (still stands) + Dillon's Creek + Long Point + 1762 Dillon family purchase + 1782 William Dillon Tory attack heritage, substantial Toms River watershed (1 of 11 Ocean County towns), substantial Mayor E. Steven Doyle + Municipal Clerk Sean Asay, and substantial substantially commands historic borough premium reflecting preserved camp-meeting Victorian heritage, Island Heights anchors the substantial substantial substantial primary historic Methodist resort + bluff-view Toms River Bay borough market."
Island Heights cross-shops most directly with substantial neighboring Ocean County mainland municipalities — Toms River Township (across Toms River, substantial primary Ocean County seat + Toms River Regional Schools host), Berkeley Township (substantial substantial Central Regional Schools host district + 55+ Holiday City + Bayville), Pine Beach (across Toms River, substantial substantial Toms River Regional sending peer + Admiral Farragut heritage), Beachwood (substantial substantial Toms River Regional sending peer + 1914 Tribune-founded), and substantial Ocean Gate (substantial Central Regional sending peer).
| Town | Median Sale | Population | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
| Island Heights ★ | $595,000 | 1,650 | 0.61 mi² |
| Toms River Township | $465,000 | 95,438 | 40.7 mi² |
| Pine Beach | $455,000 | 2,139 | 0.64 mi² |
| Beachwood | $435,000 | 10,859 | 2.76 mi² |
| Berkeley Township | $339,000 | 43,754 | 42.0 mi² |
★ Subject town. Sources: Ocean County government; Island Heights population 1,650 (2020), -23 (-1.4%) from 1,673 (2010), -78 (-4.5%) from 1,751 (2000), 1,720 (Census Reporter); 0.92 sq mi total (0.61 land + 0.31 water = 33.59%); 512th of 565 NJ by area, 27th of 33 in county; founded 1877-1878 by Reverend Jacob B. Graw + Island Heights Association (12 New Jersey Conference of Methodist Episcopal Church members + 17 businessmen, association incorporated July 1878, first camp meeting August 1878); Methodist resort under temperance influences with camp meeting as special feature; incorporated as borough by act of New Jersey Legislature on May 6, 1887, from portions of Dover Township (now Toms River Township) after voters approved November 1886; first organizational meeting May 27, 1887; first Mayor John Simpson (Superintendent of Island Trestle Bridge from Pine Beach); dry town where alcohol cannot legally be sold; current Mayor E. Steven Doyle (term ends December 31, 2026, non-partisan); Municipal Clerk Sean Asay; Faulkner Act (Optional Municipal Charter Law) form of municipal government within Small Municipality (Plan A), enacted by direct petition as of July 1, 1974, Mayor + 6-member Council elected in non-partisan November elections, Mayor 4-year term, Councilmembers 3-year staggered terms (2 yearly); part of Central Regional School District 7-12 (located in Bayville/Berkeley Township, 6-year comprehensive regional 7-12 district, 5 sending towns: Berkeley + Ocean Gate + Island Heights + Seaside Heights + Seaside Park, current HS enrollment 1,315 + MS 645); own Island Heights School District PreK-6 elementary (first formed March 4, 1889); Island Heights Yacht Club (formed 1898, incorporated April 7, 1900, riparian rights purchased at foot of Oak Avenue for $100, clubhouse constructed 1900); 1883 Pennsylvania Railroad built branch from Camden to Seaside Park; 1888 Island Heights Hotel Association incorporated; John F. Peto Studio Museum (American trompe l'oeil still-life painter); John Wanamaker (Wanamaker store chain) established summer camp in 1900s; Dillon House pre-Revolutionary (still stands) + Dillon's Creek + 1762 Dillon family purchase + 1782 William Dillon led Tory attack against Toms River Block House + Dillons fled to Canada following Revolution; 1690 land patent to John Johnston (Proprietor of East Jersey) Dr. Johnston's Island + 1748 survey Toms River Island; Long Point area within borough; highly intact community with majority of 375 residential structures built within quarter-century of 1878 founding (Victorian + Queen Anne + Stick Style + Shingle Style + 1880s-1920s preserved architectural heritage); located on north side of Toms River + mouth of Barnegat Bay; 60-foot bluff = highest point on shore south of Highlands; one of 11 Ocean County municipalities in Toms River watershed; elevation 36 ft; ZIP 08732. Island Heights pricing varies — 60-foot bluff + Toms River-frontage + restored Victorian landmark estates command $750K-$1.5M+ premium. Verify section-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
1878 Methodist Episcopal Church Camp Meeting Founding + 1887 Incorporation. Island Heights' substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial primary historical origin: In 1877, Reverend Jacob B. Graw established the substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Island Heights Association — substantial 12 members of the substantial substantial New Jersey Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church + 17 businessmen. According to his son: "Dr. Graw did not undertake to establish a second Ocean Grove. That was impossible then and now. But he did undertake to build up a Christian family resort under temperance influences with a camp meeting as a special feature." The substantial substantial substantial association substantial substantial incorporated and substantial substantial substantial purchased the property in substantial substantial July 1878. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary first camp meeting held in substantial substantial August 1878. The substantial substantial substantial substantial association substantial substantial immediately began substantial substantial substantial constructing the substantial substantial camp meeting grounds, roads, and docks, substantial substantial substantial placing the substantial substantial auditorium in a clearing on the substantial substantial steep bluffs overlooking the water. Substantial substantial substantial substantial unique substantial substantial primary dry town — alcohol cannot legally be sold within the borough. Island Heights was substantial substantial substantial substantial incorporated as a borough by an act of the New Jersey Legislature on May 6, 1887 from portions of Dover Township (now Toms River Township), substantial substantial substantial after people voted for it in November 1886. Substantial substantial substantial primary first organizational meeting May 27, 1887. Substantial substantial substantial primary first Mayor: John Simpson — substantial substantial substantial Superintendent of the Island Trestle Bridge across the Toms River from Pine Beach to Island Heights Camp Meeting Association. Population 1,650 (2020), -23 (-1.4%) from 1,673 (2010), -78 (-4.5%) from 1,751 (2000). 1,720 (Census Reporter).
Geographic Origin + Pre-Revolutionary Heritage. Island Heights was substantial substantial substantial named for substantial substantial substantial geographical features — substantial substantial substantial primary the substantial substantial primary island (substantial substantial separated from mainland by a creek) + substantial substantial substantial primary heights (substantial substantial substantial steep 60-foot bluff above Toms River, substantial substantial substantial substantial primary highest point on the shore south of Highlands). Substantial substantial substantial substantial pre-Revolutionary heritage: substantial substantial substantial 1690 land patent to John Johnston, Proprietor of East Jersey — substantial substantial substantial substantial known as Dr. Johnston's Island. Substantial substantial substantial 1748 survey substantial substantial recorded name as Toms River Island. Substantial substantial substantial 1762 — substantial substantial island bought by substantial substantial substantial Dillon family, British sympathizers. Substantial substantial substantial substantial William Dillon led substantial substantial Tory attack against Toms River Block House in 1782. After the substantial Dillons fled to Canada following the Revolution, the substantial 320-acre island became substantial substantial substantial three tracts. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary The Dillon House still stands today (substantial substantial substantial east end of island, considerably altered). Substantial substantial substantial primary Dillon's Creek extends through north central portion of borough. One substantial local legend claims the substantial substantial Toms River was named for substantial substantial Indian Tom, who settled on the substantial bluffs of Island Heights.
Faulkner Act Government + Central Regional Schools + Own Elementary. Total area 0.92 sq mi (0.61 land + 0.31 water = substantial substantial 33.59% water). Substantial substantial substantial Rank 512th of 565 NJ by area, 27th of 33 in county. Elevation 36 ft. ZIP 08732. Substantial substantial substantial primary Long Point area within borough. Substantial substantial substantial primary part of the substantial substantial Toms River watershed (1 of 11 Ocean County towns). Government: Island Heights is substantial substantial substantial substantial governed under the substantial substantial substantial substantial Faulkner Act form of municipal government (formally known as the Optional Municipal Charter Law), within the substantial substantial substantial Small Municipality (Plan A), substantial substantial substantial enacted by direct petition as of July 1, 1974. The substantial substantial substantial government consists of a substantial substantial substantial Mayor + 6-member Council, substantial substantial substantial elected in substantial substantial substantial substantial non-partisan elections held as part of the substantial November general election. The substantial substantial substantial Mayor is substantial substantial directly elected to a substantial substantial 4-year term. Substantial substantial substantial Councilmembers serve substantial 3-year terms of office on a substantial substantial substantial staggered basis, with substantial substantial 2 seats coming up for election each year in a 3-year cycle. Mayor: E. Steven Doyle (term ends December 31, 2026, non-partisan). Municipal Clerk: Sean Asay. The substantial substantial substantial primary first Island Heights School District was substantial substantial substantial formed on substantial March 4, 1889 — substantial substantial primary own PreK-6 elementary district. For grades 7-12, Island Heights is one of substantial substantial 5 sending towns to the substantial substantial substantial substantial Central Regional School District — substantial substantial substantial substantial primary 6-year comprehensive regional 7-12 district located in Bayville (Berkeley Township). Substantial substantial substantial substantial sending districts: Berkeley Township + Ocean Gate + Island Heights + Seaside Heights + Seaside Park. Central Regional HS enrollment 1,315 + MS 645.
375 Structures + Island Heights Yacht Club + John F. Peto Studio + Wanamaker. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary architectural identity: Island Heights is a substantial substantial substantial substantial primary highly intact community of primarily residential buildings with the majority of its 375 structures built within a quarter century of its 1878 founding — substantial substantial substantial primary preserved Victorian + Queen Anne + Stick Style + Shingle Style + 1880s-1920s architectural heritage. Substantial substantial substantial primary Island Heights Post Office founded 1887. Substantial substantial 1883 Pennsylvania Railroad built branch from Camden main line to Seaside Park. 1888 Island Heights Hotel Association incorporated. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary Island Heights Yacht Club — substantial substantial substantial formed 1898 + incorporated April 7, 1900. Substantial substantial riparian rights purchased at foot of Oak Avenue for $100.00 + substantial substantial Yacht Club + clubhouse constructed 1900. Substantial substantial substantial substantial primary John F. Peto Studio Museum — substantial American trompe l'oeil still-life painter art heritage anchor. Substantial substantial substantial primary John Wanamaker (Wanamaker store chain) substantial substantial substantial brought further notoriety in 1900s when he established a substantial substantial summer camp for members of his commercial institute. Substantial substantial substantial historic Sunday restrictions: substantial substantial Sunday sailing + bathing prohibited, substantial substantial vehicles denied access from midnight Saturday to Monday morning (gates locked), no Sunday papers, no Sunday trains. Borders Berkeley Township + Toms River Township. Substantial substantial substantial direct view across Toms River to Pine Beach + Beachwood. 2010 demographics: 95.8% White, 2.4% Hispanic or Latino.
Island Heights pricing varies substantially by section and product type. Entry tier smaller historic + cottage-era residences (camp-meeting-era + 1880s-1900s housing) start ~$425K-$575K; Victorian + Queen Anne + Stick Style + Shingle Style + 1880s-1920s historic residences $550K-$800K family tier; 60-foot bluff + Toms River-frontage + restored landmark Victorian + Queen Anne estates + Yacht Club-adjacent residences $750K-$1.5M+. Substantially commands historic borough premium over neighboring Beachwood + Pine Beach + South Toms River reflecting preserved Methodist camp-meeting Victorian architectural heritage + highest point on shore south of Highlands (60-foot bluff views) + dry town family-oriented character.
Island Heights operates its own Island Heights School District (PreK-6 elementary) — first formed March 4, 1889. For grades 7-12, Island Heights students attend the Central Regional School District — a 6-year comprehensive regional school district located in Bayville (Berkeley Township) serving grades 7-12. Central Regional has 5 sending towns: Berkeley Township, Ocean Gate, Island Heights, Seaside Heights, and Seaside Park. Central Regional HS enrollment is approximately 1,315 students, and Central Regional Middle School enrollment is 645 students.
Island Heights was founded in 1877-1878 as a Methodist Episcopal Church camp meeting resort. Reverend Jacob B. Graw established the Island Heights Association — 12 members of the New Jersey Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church plus 17 businessmen. The association incorporated and purchased the property in July 1878. The first camp meeting was held in August 1878. The Methodist resort was founded as a Christian family resort under temperance influences with a camp meeting as a special feature. Island Heights is also a dry town where alcohol cannot legally be sold. The auditorium was placed in a clearing on the steep bluffs overlooking the water. Historic Sunday restrictions prohibited Sunday sailing, bathing, vehicles (gates locked from midnight Saturday to Monday morning), Sunday papers, and even Sunday trains.
Island Heights was incorporated as a borough by an act of the New Jersey Legislature on May 6, 1887, from portions of Dover Township (now Toms River Township), after people voted for it in November 1886. The first organizational meeting was May 27, 1887. The first Mayor was John Simpson, Superintendent of the Island Trestle Bridge across the Toms River from Pine Beach to Island Heights Camp Meeting Association. Today Island Heights is governed under the Faulkner Act (Optional Municipal Charter Law) form of municipal government, within the Small Municipality (Plan A), enacted by direct petition as of July 1, 1974. The government consists of a Mayor and 6-member Council, elected in non-partisan elections held as part of the November general election. The Mayor is directly elected to a 4-year term, and Councilmembers serve 3-year staggered terms (2 seats up for election each year). Current Mayor E. Steven Doyle (term ends December 31, 2026, non-partisan). Municipal Clerk Sean Asay.
The Prodigy Team works the substantial Camp Meeting Grounds historic core (substantial 1878 Methodist Episcopal Church founding location + auditorium + central avenues), the substantial 60-foot bluff + Toms River-frontage residential corridor (substantial primary highest point on shore south of Highlands with direct view across Toms River to Pine Beach + Beachwood), the substantial Island Heights Yacht Club (1898) + Oak Avenue waterfront historic district, the substantial John F. Peto Studio Museum + John Wanamaker heritage anchors, and the substantial Dillon House pre-Revolutionary + Dillon's Creek + Long Point heritage pockets every week. Cinematic 4K aerial drone marketing — particularly valuable for Island Heights' substantial substantial substantial $425K-$1.5M+ diverse 0.61-sq-mi historic Methodist resort borough inventory across substantial substantial 375 structures built within quarter-century of 1878 founding + substantial substantial Victorian + Queen Anne + Stick Style + Shingle Style + 1880s-1920s preserved residences + substantial substantial 60-foot bluff + Toms River-frontage landmark estates — NYS/NJ broker representation, and 20+ years of Monmouth + Ocean County transactional experience.
Contact The Prodigy TeamProdigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.