Prodigy Real Estate

What Sold in Westfield, NJ This Fall: 91 Home Sales, With the Age and Size of Each House

Anthony Licciardello  |  November 22, 2026

Westfield, NJ

What Sold in Westfield, NJ This Fall: 91 Home Sales, With the Age and Size of Each House

Union County · Sales Ledger · Fall 2026 · Westfield, NJ

Ninety-one closings since August, fourteen of them at $2 million or more, and a top sale on Wyandotte Trail that closed $625,000 under its first asking price. Here is what sold in Westfield, how old each house was, and how much floor area the money bought.

91
Closings · Aug 1 to Nov 20
$3.375M
Top Sale · 909 Wyandotte Trail
14
Sales at $2 Million or More
61 of 91
Closed at $1 Million or More
The Argument in Brief
  • Two-thirds of Westfield's fall sales cleared $1 million. Sixty-one of 91 closings did, and 40 of those closed at $1.5 million or more.
  • The $2 million tier belongs to two kinds of house: brand-new construction, and homes from the 1910s and 1920s near the center of town.
  • Westfield is an older town than its prices suggest. Twelve of the 37 homes with a build year on record went up before 1940, the oldest in 1900.
  • The first asking price still gets tested, even at the top. The season's highest sale closed 16 percent below where it started, while a 1925 colonial on North Chestnut Street sold $233,000 over.

Westfield sells more seven-figure houses in a season than most Union County towns sell in a year. We track the town month by month, most recently in our August market report. This ledger takes the longer view: every closing from the start of August through November 20, by address.

The Garden State MLS feeds recorded 91 closed sales at Westfield addresses in that window, worth about $129 million combined. Sixty-one closed at $1 million or more. Fourteen closed at $2 million or more. Thirty closed below $1 million, and ten of those below $700,000, most of them condominiums. The middle sale of the 91 was $1,305,000.

I
The Top of the Tape

Fourteen Westfield Homes Sold for $2 Million or More, Led by Wyandotte Trail at $3,375,000

Sale of the Season
909 Wyandotte Trail
$3,375,000
6 Beds6.5 Baths0.48 AcreRecords: Built 1957Closed Oct 20
The highest Westfield closing of the period. First listed in April at $3,999,999, reduced twice, and sold on October 20.

The highest sale of the period closed on October 20. Nine-oh-nine Wyandotte Trail, a six-bedroom home with six and a half baths on just under half an acre in the Indian Forest section, sold for $3,375,000. The records still carry a 1957 build year. Public records also show the property changed hands in March 2024 for $1,505,000, so the house that sold this fall is not the house that sold then.

14 Sales
$2 Million or More
From $2,000,000 to $3,375,000 in under four months

Second was 26 Manchester Drive at $2,999,053 on August 17, a six-bedroom home built in 2025. Third was 714 East Broad Street, with seven bedrooms and six baths, at $2,900,000 on August 20. Fourth was 615 Lenox Avenue, built in 1918, at $2,804,500 for 3,562 square feet. That is about $787 a foot for a house more than a century old.

New construction fills much of the rest. A 2026 colonial at 547 Shackamaxon Drive sold for its full asking price of $2,499,999 with 4,000 square feet. A 2026 home at 125 Tudor Oval brought $2,275,000, and a 2015 home at 771 Boulevard brought $2,175,000. Between them sit two 1925 houses, 224 North Chestnut Street at $2,225,000 and 122 Stanmore Place at $2,044,999.

For where these blocks rank over a longer period, see our report on the ten most expensive streets in Westfield. All 14 sales at $2 million and above are below.

Built Since 2000ContemporaryMid-CenturyHistoric
01909 Wyandotte Trl
$3,375,000
Mid-Century
Built
1957
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
6 / 6.5
Closed
Oct 20
0226 Manchester Dr
$2,999,053
Built Since 2000
Built
2025
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
6 / 6
Closed
Aug 17
03714 E Broad St
$2,900,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
7 / 6
Closed
Aug 20
04615 Lenox Ave
$2,804,500
Historic
Built
1918
Sq Ft
3,562
Bd / Ba
6 / 5
Closed
Aug 28
05564 Highland Ave
$2,600,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
3,435
Bd / Ba
6 / 5
Closed
Sep 18
06547 Shackamaxon Dr
$2,499,999
Built Since 2000
Built
2026
Sq Ft
4,000
Bd / Ba
6 / 6.5
Closed
Oct 15
07125 Tudor Oval
$2,275,000
Built Since 2000
Built
2026
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
6 / 6
Closed
Aug 3
08206 Munsee Way
$2,231,000
Contemporary
Built
1974
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
4 / 5
Closed
Aug 7
09224 N Chestnut St
$2,225,000
Historic
Built
1925
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
5 / 4
Closed
Nov 2
10771 Boulevard
$2,175,000
Built Since 2000
Built
2015
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
5 / 5
Closed
Sep 30
11820 Standish Ave
$2,150,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
6 / —
Closed
Oct 8
12221 Delaware St
$2,100,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
6 / —
Closed
Nov 12
13122 Stanmore Pl
$2,044,999
Historic
Built
1925
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
6 / 6
Closed
Sep 18
141091 Minisink Way
$2,000,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
4 / 4
Closed
Aug 5

All closings 2026. Bd / Ba is bedrooms and baths. Built is the year in MLS or tax records, which for a rebuilt home can be the year of the original house. Square footage is the listing figure where one was published. A dash means the figure was not published.

II
List Price Versus Sold Price

Asking Price Versus Sold Price in Westfield: Three Results at the Top

+$233,023
224 North Chestnut Street
Listed $1,991,977 · sold $2,225,000

Three of the top sales show three different outcomes for a seller's asking price.

Wyandotte Trail came to market on April 9 at $3,999,999. It was reduced to $3,750,000 on May 1 and later to $3,499,999, and it closed at $3,375,000. That is $624,999, or about 16 percent, below the first number. It was still the highest sale in town.

North Chestnut Street went the other way. The 1925 center hall colonial was listed at $1,991,977, just under the $2 million line, and sold for $2,225,000. That is $233,023 over asking. And on Shackamaxon Drive, the new colonial sold for exactly what the builder asked.

⚖️ Asking Price and Sold Price · Three Westfield Sales
909 Wyandotte Trail
Listed
$3,999,999
First list price
April 2026
→
Sold
$3,375,000
Sold Oct 2026
$624,999 under
224 North Chestnut Street
Listed
$1,991,977
List price
Built 1925
→
Sold
$2,225,000
Sold Nov 2026
$233,023 over
547 Shackamaxon Drive
Listed
$2,499,999
List price
Built 2026
→
Sold
$2,499,999
Sold Oct 2026
At asking

The pattern is one we see across Westfield. A price set just below a round number draws a crowd and gets bid up. A price set well above the last comparable sale waits, gets cut, and usually closes near where the market was all along.

III
Age of the Homes

How Old Westfield Homes Are: From 1900 on Rahway Avenue to 2026 on Shackamaxon Drive

🕰️ 126 Years of Westfield Housing · Sales by Year Built
1900
734 Rahway Avenue
$705,000
2026
547 Shackamaxon Drive
$2,499,999
1900
1925
1950
1975
2000
2025
Before 19401940 to 19681972 to 1986Built since 2015
Each dot is one closing, placed by the build year on record. 37 sales with a build year.
12 of 37
Built Before 1940
Four of them in a single year, 1925

Thirty-seven of the 91 sales have a build year on record. Twelve of those homes went up before 1940, fifteen between 1940 and 1968, five between 1972 and 1986, and five since 2015. Nothing in the sample was built between 1987 and 2014.

The prewar homes did not sell at a discount for their age. Ten of the twelve closed above $1.4 million. Lenox Avenue, built in 1918, was the fourth-highest sale in town. A 1911 home at 617 Lawrence Avenue brought $1,670,000, and a 1923 home at 546 Alden Avenue brought $1,750,000 in nine days. The oldest house on the list, a two-bedroom from 1900 at 734 Rahway Avenue, sold for $705,000.

The postwar homes cover the widest range. A 1947 home at 905 Harding Street and a 1950 home at 532 Kimball Turn each sold just under $2 million. A 1957 home at 922 Cleveland Avenue sold for $899,250. The difference is what was done to the house after it was built, and how large it is now.

🏡 When the Westfield Homes Were Built · 37 Sales
Before 194012 sales
1940 to 196815 sales
1972 to 19865 sales
2015 to 20265 sales

Counts cover the 37 closings in this ledger with a build year in MLS or tax records.

IV
Square Footage

Square Footage in Westfield: From $352 to $890 a Foot

$890 / sq ft
740 Willow Grove Road
1,404 sq ft · sold $1,250,000

Fourteen of the 91 sales have a usable square footage on record. Price per foot runs from $352 to $890, and thirteen of the fourteen sold above $500 a foot.

The highest figures belong to smaller houses on good lots. Willow Grove Road, at 1,404 square feet, sold for $1,250,000, or $890 a foot. Fairacres Avenue, a 1922 home recorded at 1,900 square feet, sold for $859 a foot. At those sizes a buyer is paying for the land and the location, and the house comes along with it.

The larger homes land between $500 and $800. Lenox Avenue sold at $787 a foot and 564 Highland Avenue at $757, both with about 3,500 square feet. The new colonial on Shackamaxon Drive, at 4,000 square feet, sold at $625. Among the condominiums, a two-bedroom at 260 Prospect Street sold for $639 a foot and a one-bedroom at 523 Trinity Place for $595.

📐 Price Per Square Foot · Ten Westfield Closings
740 Willow Grove Rd · 1,404 sq ft$890
736 Fairacres Ave · 1,900 sq ft$859
424 Colonial Ave · 2,264 sq ft$795
615 Lenox Ave · 3,562 sq ft$787
564 Highland Ave · 3,435 sq ft$757
707 Prospect St · 1,504 sq ft$664
547 Shackamaxon Dr · 4,000 sq ft$625
935 Minisink Way · 3,818 sq ft$524
240 Clark St · 2,502 sq ft$510
617 Lawrence Ave · 3,324 sq ft$502

Dark bars are homes under 2,000 sq ft. Each figure is the closed price divided by the square footage published with the listing.

🚩
Read Square Footage With Care

Most Westfield listings are published without a square footage, which is why only 14 of these 91 sales have one. Where a figure does appear, it may or may not include a finished basement or a third floor, and a tax-record figure can lag behind an addition by years. Before you compare two Westfield homes by price per foot, confirm that both numbers measure the same thing.

For Westfield Sellers
Which of these sales is the right comparison for your house?

Two houses built the same decade sold more than $1 million apart this fall. We will line your home up against the closings that actually match it, and tell you what it is worth as it stands.

Get Your Home Value →

V
The Rest of the Tape

Speed, Condos and the Rest of the Westfield Tape

7 Days
1005 Cranford Avenue
Built 1968 · sold $1,550,000

The fastest sales took a week. A 1968 home at 1005 Cranford Avenue sold for $1,550,000 in seven days, and a three-bedroom at 105 Summit Court sold for $985,000 in the same time. Five more homes, priced from $899,250 to $1,975,000, went in nine days.

The slowest were at opposite ends of the market. The new home on Manchester Drive took 166 days to reach its $2,999,053 closing. A five-bedroom at 722 Rahway Avenue took 140 days and closed at $770,857. New construction priced near $3 million and an older house that needs work both have a narrower pool of buyers.

935 Minisink Way
$1,999,999
Mid-Century
Built
1959
Sq Ft
3,818
Days
13
Closed
Aug 7
905 Harding St
$1,975,000
Mid-Century
Built
1947
Sq Ft
—
Days
9
Closed
Aug 3
532 Kimball Turn
$1,970,000
Mid-Century
Built
1950
Sq Ft
—
Days
12
Closed
Aug 6
237 Elizabeth Ave
$1,960,000
Built Since 2000
Built
2015
Sq Ft
—
Days
43
Closed
Oct 14
881 Village Green
$1,950,000
Mid-Century
Built
1956
Sq Ft
—
Days
12
Closed
Aug 31
424 Colonial Ave
$1,800,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
2,264
Days
45
Closed
Aug 24
546 Alden Ave
$1,750,000
Historic
Built
1923
Sq Ft
—
Days
9
Closed
Oct 7
199 Lincoln Rd
$1,695,000
Historic
Built
1925
Sq Ft
—
Days
16
Closed
Aug 21
617 Lawrence Ave
$1,670,000
Historic
Built
1911
Sq Ft
3,324
Days
22
Closed
Aug 28
736 Fairacres Ave
$1,632,500
Historic
Built
1922
Sq Ft
1,900
Days
11
Closed
Sep 21
1005 Cranford Ave
$1,550,000
Mid-Century
Built
1968
Sq Ft
—
Days
7
Closed
Oct 1
718 Bradford Ave
$1,500,000
Historic
Built
1930
Sq Ft
—
Days
—
Closed
Sep 22
720 Harding St
$1,500,000
Mid-Century
Built
1941
Sq Ft
—
Days
10
Closed
Aug 7
765 Clark St
$1,450,000
Historic
Built
1924
Sq Ft
—
Days
—
Closed
Oct 5
559 Parkview Ave
$1,435,000
Historic
Built
1908
Sq Ft
—
Days
22
Closed
Oct 2
537 Wychwood Rd
$1,395,000
Mid-Century
Built
1940
Sq Ft
—
Days
12
Closed
Aug 11
957 Willow Grove Rd
$1,305,000
Mid-Century
Built
1950
Sq Ft
—
Days
16
Closed
Aug 14
555 Shackamaxon Dr
$1,275,000
Historic
Built
1925
Sq Ft
—
Days
20
Closed
Aug 13
240 Clark St
$1,275,000
Mid-Century
Built
1952
Sq Ft
2,502
Days
—
Closed
Oct 1
941 South Ave W
$1,275,000
Mid-Century
Built
1948
Sq Ft
—
Days
14
Closed
Aug 3
740 Willow Grove Rd
$1,250,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
1,404
Days
19
Closed
Aug 24
546 Carleton Rd
$1,100,000
Contemporary
Built
1972
Sq Ft
—
Days
13
Closed
Sep 3
221 Ayliffe Ave
$1,060,000
Mid-Century
Built
1940
Sq Ft
—
Days
19
Closed
Aug 14

Closings from $1,000,000 to $1,999,999 with a build year or square footage on record. Days is days on market as reported with the closed listing.

$324,900
Lowest Closing
A two-bedroom condominium on Sandra Circle

Below $1 million, Westfield is a different market. Thirty sales closed there, and the ten under $700,000 were mostly condominiums and attached homes. Units on Sandra Circle sold for $324,900 and $335,000. A one-bedroom at 523 Trinity Place sold for $410,000. Two-bedroom condominiums near downtown, on Prospect Street and Walnut Street, sold between $570,000 and $650,000.

707 Prospect St
$999,000
Mid-Century
Built
1941
Sq Ft
1,504
Days
13
Closed
Sep 3
105 Summit Ct
$985,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
1,300
Days
7
Closed
Sep 8
922 Cleveland Ave
$899,250
Mid-Century
Built
1957
Sq Ft
—
Days
9
Closed
Aug 17
112 Cacciola Pl
$760,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
2,160
Days
75
Closed
Sep 2
120 S Scotch Plains Ave
$750,000
Contemporary
Built
1979
Sq Ft
—
Days
36
Closed
Aug 17
734 Rahway Ave
$705,000
Historic
Built
1900
Sq Ft
—
Days
85
Closed
Oct 2
260 Walnut St, Unit 10
$650,000
Mid-CenturyTownhome / Condo
Built
1949
Sq Ft
—
Days
29
Closed
Aug 7
260 Prospect St, Unit C12
$619,000
ContemporaryTownhome / Condo
Built
1979
Sq Ft
968
Days
—
Closed
Sep 16
523 Trinity Pl, Unit 2DS
$410,000
ContemporaryTownhome / Condo
Built
1986
Sq Ft
689
Days
53
Closed
Sep 4

Closings under $1,000,000 with a build year or square footage on record. Forty-five more closings across all price ranges had neither on record; they are counted in the totals and not shown as cards.

Above the Streets · Westfield From the Air

Current listings are on our Westfield homes for sale page. If you are new to the town, start with our guide to moving to Westfield.

💡
Insider Tip

In Westfield, where you set the price matters as much as what the house is. The colonial on North Chestnut Street was listed at $1,991,977 and sold for $2,225,000. The home on Wyandotte Trail was listed at $3,999,999 and sold for $3,375,000 after two cuts and six months. If you are choosing between a price that feels safe and a price that feels ambitious, look at how each of those two sellers spent their summer.

Broker's Note

"Westfield buyers will pay for a 1920s house and they will pay for a brand-new one. What they will not do is pay a first asking price that the last three sales on the street do not support. Fourteen homes closed at $2 million or more this fall, and the ones that sold fastest were the ones priced from the comparables."

Anthony Licciardello, Broker, The Prodigy Team

Anthony Licciardello
Broker, The Prodigy Team

Anthony Licciardello, Broker, The Prodigy Team

The Prodigy Team Advantage
Why the Buyer for Your Westfield Home May Be Coming From New York
Two decades in the business
5,000+ closed transactions
Dual New York and New Jersey broker licenses
Former Director of Community Affairs, Bloomberg Administration
Member, Staten Island Growth Management Task Force

Buyers leaving New York for a walkable downtown and a direct train often put Westfield first on the list. The Prodigy Team is licensed on both sides of the bridge, so we work with those buyers before they ever tour a New Jersey home. Our digital reach is built for that pipeline: a YouTube channel with more than 400,000 views over the past year, a relocation community of more than 26,500 members on Facebook, and more than 17 million impressions on Pinterest.

Our in-house aerial series, Above the Streets, shows a home in the context buyers care about: the lot, the block and the town around it.

Thinking About Selling in Westfield?
Find out where your home sits on this fall's tape.

Call 718-873-7345 or start with a home value review.

See Why Clients Choose Us

Westfield Home Sales, Fall 2026: Questions and Answers

Top Sale

What was the most expensive home sold in Westfield in fall 2026?

909 Wyandotte Trail, which closed on October 20, 2026 at $3,375,000. It has six bedrooms and six and a half baths on about half an acre, and was first listed in April 2026 at $3,999,999.

Over $2 Million

How many Westfield homes sold for $2 million or more?

Fourteen, between August 1 and November 20, 2026, at prices from $2,000,000 to $3,375,000. Sixty-one of the 91 closings in the period were at $1 million or more.

Age

How old are the homes that sell in Westfield?

Of 37 closings in this ledger with a build year on record, 12 were built before 1940, 15 between 1940 and 1968, five between 1972 and 1986, and five since 2015. The oldest dated from 1900 and the newest from 2026.

Price Per Foot

What do Westfield homes sell for per square foot?

Among the 14 closings with a published square footage, the range ran from $352 to $890 per square foot, and 13 of the 14 sold above $500 a foot.

Condos

What do condominiums sell for in Westfield?

This period, condominium and attached-home sales ran from $324,900 on Sandra Circle to $675,000 for a unit on First Street, with a two-bedroom at 111 Prospect Street closing at $1,109,500.

🗺️ Explore Nearby · Union County

Sources and data notes. Closed sale prices and dates: Garden State Multiple Listing Service closed-sale records as displayed by Movoto and Homes.com, retrieved November 21, 2026, covering 91 closings at Westfield addresses from August 1 through November 20, 2026. Build years, bedroom and bath counts, days on market and listing square footage: GSMLS listing records as displayed by Homes.com and participating IDX sites. Prior sale and price history for 909 Wyandotte Trail and list prices for 224 North Chestnut Street and 547 Shackamaxon Drive: public records and GSMLS listing history as displayed by participating IDX sites. Price-per-square-foot figures are the closed price divided by the square footage shown. Totals and counts are calculated from this ledger and describe these 91 closings only; they are not a town-wide median. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Work With Us

Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.