Prodigy Real Estate

The Divergence Index: 13 Union County Towns Where the Median Price and the Per-Foot Price Tell Opposite Stories

Anthony Licciardello  |  November 16, 2026

Union County

The Divergence Index: 13 Union County Towns Where the Median Price and the Per-Foot Price Tell Opposite Stories

Plainfield vs Elizabeth: $164,886 Apart on the Median, $12 Apart Per Square Foot

By Anthony Licciardello, Broker · The Prodigy Team · Published November 15, 2026 · Plainfield and Elizabeth, New Jersey

Union County's two busiest residential markets look like different worlds on the headline and like the same market per square foot. One of those two readings is measuring price. The other is measuring floor area.

$164,886
Median gap between the towns
$12
Per-foot gap between the towns
161
Combined October closings
10 days
Swing in relative speed
The Argument in Brief

These are the two busiest residential markets in Union County, and on the headline they look like different worlds: Elizabeth’s median sale price is $654,545 and rising, Plainfield’s is $489,659 and falling. Measured per square foot they are twelve dollars apart — $332 against $320 — and the gap is closing fast. Elizabeth’s per-foot price fell 3.8 percent this year while Plainfield’s rose 31.1 percent. The two towns also crossed on speed: a year ago Elizabeth sold faster, and today Plainfield does.

Two Numbers The $12 Gap The Crossing Volume If You’re Selling If You’re Buying FAQ

OneThe Two Towns, Side by Side

Three months ending October 2026, both read from the same source on the same day. Plainfield first, Elizabeth second, in every row.

Median sale price

$489,659

Plainfield · down 12.6%

$654,545

Elizabeth · up 4.0%

Price per square foot

$320

Plainfield · up 31.1%

$332

Elizabeth · down 3.8%

Median days on market

32

Plainfield · from 39

39

Elizabeth · from 36

Homes sold, October

58

Plainfield · from 74

103

Elizabeth · from 110

Read down the first row and Elizabeth is the stronger market by $164,886 and a16.6-point swing in direction. Read down the second row and the two towns are trading within four percent of each other, with Plainfield gaining and Elizabeth giving ground. Both rows are correct. Only one of them is about price.

TwoWhat a $164,886 Median Gap Is Actually Made Of

If two towns sit twelve dollars apart per square foot, a $164,886 difference in their median sale price is not a difference in what housing costs. It is a difference in how much housing is being sold.

🎯

$12
the entire per-foot gap between the two towns

Elizabeth $332, Plainfield $320 — 3.8 percent apart. Their medians are 33.7 percent apart. The median is measuring floor area; the per-foot figure is measuring price.

A median is the middle closing, whatever size it happened to be. Elizabeth’s middle closing is simply a larger piece of property than Plainfield’s. Divide each sale by its floor area before ranking them, as the per-foot measure does, and the two markets turn out to be charging almost the same thing for the same amount of house.

That reversal is not unique to these two. Four miles north, Garwood posts a median 24.8 percent above Kenilworth’s while pricing 22.6 percent below it per square foot — the same inversion, running the opposite way, in a pair of boroughs a tenth the size. Seven of the county’s thirteen towns change rank by two places or more when you order them per foot instead of by median, and that table is in the Garwood and Kenilworth comparison.

The direction of travel is the more useful half. Elizabeth’s per-foot price fell 3.8 percent over the year and Plainfield’s rose 31.1 percent. Working backwards from those published percentages, Elizabeth was near $345 a foot a year ago and Plainfield near $244 — a gap of roughly $101. It is now $12. That back-calculation is this desk’s arithmetic off Redfin’s own published percentages, not a figure Redfin prints, and it carries whatever rounding those percentages carry.

📐Why 31.1 Percent Gets a Caveat and Still Gets Printed

A 31.1 percent move in a city’s per-foot price in one year is large. It rests on 58 October closings, which is the fifth largest sample among the thirteen Union County towns with published figures, so it is not a small-sample artefact in the way a fourteen-sale borough would be. It is reported here as published, from one provider, for one window. It is not reconciled against GSMLS or Zillow, which run different datasets and will not match. One quarter is a reading, not a trend.

⚠️Read This Carefully

What This Does Not Say

It does not say a Plainfield house and an Elizabeth house of the same size are worth the same money. Price per square foot ignores land, condition, finish level, parking, taxes and where in the town the house sits, and those differences are real and in places large. What the figure does say is that the headline gap between these two towns is mostly a size gap, and anyone using the median difference as a measure of relative value is measuring the wrong thing.

Anthony Licciardello, Broker, The Prodigy Team

Thinking of selling?

A $164,886 Gap That Is Really $12. Which One Is Your House?

In Plainfield the headline says prices fell 12.6 percent while every square foot sold got 31.1 percent dearer. In Elizabeth it says the opposite of what the per-foot figure says. Neither number was built to price an address.

Anthony Licciardello has spent twenty-two years and more than five thousand closings learning which number to price against. The per-foot comparables, the mix-adjusted read and the transfer-fee arithmetic are run before your house goes live — not after the first price cut. Broker, dual-licensed in New Jersey and New York, across seven New Jersey counties and Staten Island.

Call (718) 873-7345

Or request a pricing read at prodigyre.com — no obligation, and you keep the analysis either way.

ThreeThe Year the Two Towns Crossed on Speed

Days on market is the measure that is hardest to argue with, because it does not care what sold — only how long it took.

📈
32
Plainfield days, from 39

Plainfield took 32 days to sell the median home, down from 39 a year ago. Elizabeth took 39, up from 36. A year ago Elizabeth was the faster of the two by three days. Today Plainfield is faster by seven. That is a ten-day swing in relative speed inside twelve months, in the same county, between two markets at similar per-foot price points.

Speed and per-foot price are moving the same way in both towns, which is the reason to take them seriously together. Plainfield got faster and more expensive per foot. Elizabeth got slower and slightly cheaper per foot. Neither town’s median says any of this — Plainfield’s median fell and Elizabeth’s rose, which is the exact opposite ordering.

💡Insider Tip

A Rule for Reading Any Town

When days on market and price per square foot agree with each other and disagree with the median, trust the pair. The median is the only one of the three that changes when the mix of houses changes. Two independent measures pointing the same way against a third is the clearest signal a public dataset gives you.

FourBoth Towns Sold Fewer Homes

Whatever the price measures say, fewer houses changed hands in both towns.

Plainfield closed 58 homes in October against 74 a year earlier, a fall of 21.6 percent. Elizabeth closed 103 against 110, a fall of 6.4 percent. Elizabeth remains the highest-volume municipal market in the county among towns with published figures, and it lost the least ground of the two.

Plainfield’s combination is the one to sit with: volume down 21.6 percent, the median down 12.6 percent, the per-foot price up 31.1 percent and the market seven days faster. Fewer sales, smaller houses, higher per-foot prices, quicker closings. That is the signature of a market where the affordable end has thinned out and what remains is bid harder — and it is completely invisible in the one number most coverage quotes.

⚠️Read This Carefully

Do Not Compare These Counts to the County

Redfin publishes 308 October closings for Union County as a whole. The thirteen town pages report 584 between them. Thirteen towns cannot outsell their own county, so the municipal and county counts are drawn on different bases. Elizabeth’s 103 and Plainfield’s 58 are compared with each other here and with their own prior years, and never expressed as a share of county volume.

FiveIf You Are Selling in Either Town

The right number to price against is different in each, and in Plainfield it is not the one in the news.

Plainfield. Your town headline says prices fell 12.6 percent. Every square foot that sold this quarter went for 31.1 percent more than a year ago, and the market is seven days faster. If you set a list price off the headline you are pricing into a market that the same dataset says got sharply more expensive. Ask for closed per-foot comparables on homes within roughly 15 percent of your square footage before you accept any number derived from the median.

Plainfield is the widest case of this in Union County, but it is not the only one. Roselle Park’s median rose 3.5 percent against a 24.5 percent per-foot rise, a 21-point gap and the second widest in the county, and it is the same trap for the same reason. The borough comparison runs in Roselle Park against Roselle.

Elizabeth. Your headline says prices rose 4.0 percent, and that is the more flattering of the two readings. Per foot the market slipped 3.8 percent and it is taking three days longer to sell. Elizabeth is not a weak market — 103 closings in a month is the busiest in the county — but the headline is running ahead of the per-foot reality, by 7.8 points on the county divergence index. Price it on comparables, not on the four percent.

⭐ The Prodigy Team Advantage

We price both towns off per-foot comparables at your square footage, and we will show you the headline next to it so you can see the distance yourself. Twenty-two years and more than five thousand closings across seven New Jersey counties and Staten Island. The desk is on 718-873-7345.

$12
per-foot gap between the towns
161
closings across both in October
22
years in these markets

SixIf You Are Buying

The two towns offer opposite kinds of opportunity, and the opportunity is not where the headline puts it.

In Elizabeth, the per-foot price is falling and homes are sitting three days longer. That is the softer side of the two on the measure that holds size constant, and it is the town where a per-foot argument in negotiation is backed by the seller’s own data provider. The high median is floor area, not premium.

In Plainfield, the per-foot price is climbing hard and the market is speeding up, while the headline tells everyone prices are falling. Expect competition that the published median does not predict, and expect some sellers to be priced below where the per-foot data would put them — which is an opportunity, but a short-lived one in a market moving seven days faster.

Broker’s Note

Anthony Licciardello, Broker, The Prodigy Team

“Two towns, ten miles apart, one says up four percent and the other says down thirteen, and per square foot there is twelve dollars between them. I have had this conversation at kitchen tables in both places this autumn. The Elizabeth seller thinks she is riding a rise and the Plainfield seller thinks he has missed the boat, and the data says the Plainfield house is the one gaining. A median tells you what sold. It was never designed to tell you what your house is worth, and in these two towns right now it is actively pointing the wrong way.”

Anthony Licciardello · Broker, The Prodigy Team

Frequently Asked Questions

Question

Is Elizabeth really more expensive than Plainfield?

Per square foot, barely — $332 against $320 in the three months ending October 2026, a difference of 3.8 percent. By median sale price the gap looks far larger, $654,545 against $489,659, but that gap is mostly the size of the homes that happened to sell. A year ago the per-foot gap was roughly $101, derived from the published percentage changes; it is now $12.

Question

Why did Plainfield's median fall while its price per square foot rose?

Because Plainfield sold distinctly smaller homes this quarter than last year. The median is the middle transaction regardless of size, so a shift toward smaller properties pulls it down even when every square foot is getting more expensive. Plainfield’s median fell 12.6 percent while its per-foot price rose 31.1 percent, a 43.7-point divergence and the widest in Union County.

Question

Which town is selling faster?

Plainfield, at a median 32 days against Elizabeth’s 39. The order reversed this year: a year ago Elizabeth was faster at 36 days against Plainfield’s 39. Plainfield gained seven days and Elizabeth lost three.

Question

Did sales volume hold up in either town?

No. Plainfield closed 58 homes in October against 74 a year earlier, down 21.6 percent. Elizabeth closed 103 against 110, down 6.4 percent. Elizabeth remains the busiest municipal market in Union County among towns Redfin publishes full figures for.

Question

Should I price my Plainfield home off the 12.6 percent decline?

No. That figure describes the mix of homes that sold, not what a given house is worth. The size-adjusted measure for the same town and the same window rose 31.1 percent, and the market is seven days faster than a year ago. Price against closed sales of homes within roughly 15 percent of your square footage, looked at per foot, then adjusted for condition, lot and location.

Question

How reliable are these figures?

They are Redfin’s published municipal figures for the three months ending October 2026, read directly from each town’s housing-market page on 15 November 2026. Both towns carry solid samples by Union County standards — 103 and 58 October closings. The figures are not reconciled against GSMLS, Zillow or Realtor.com, which use different datasets and will not match. Price per square foot is computed only across sales with a recorded floor area.

Read Next

All 13 towns ranked by divergence · Summit vs Westfield · Garwood vs Kenilworth · Roselle Park vs Roselle · Union County by home type · Union County price cuts · NJ property tax appeal playbook

Sources and method. Median sale price, year-over-year median change, median price per square foot and its year-over-year change, median days on market against the prior year, and October closings against October 2025, all read from the Redfin Plainfield and Elizabeth housing-market pages on 15 November 2026 for the three months ending October 2026. The implied prior-year per-foot figures of roughly $345 and $244, and the resulting $101 gap, are this desk’s arithmetic from Redfin’s published percentage changes rather than figures Redfin prints, and inherit the rounding in those percentages. The 43.7-point divergence figure is also this desk’s own calculation. Not reconciled: Redfin reports 308 October closings for Union County while its thirteen town pages report 584 between them, so municipal and county counts rest on different bases and are never divided into one another here. Figures are reported as published and are not matched against GSMLS, Zillow or Realtor.com, which run separate datasets. Price per square foot is a median across sales carrying a recorded floor area and does not adjust for land, condition, finish or location within a town.

Which Number Applies to Your Address?

Give us the street and the square footage. We will put the per-foot comparables for homes your size next to your town’s headline so you can see the distance before you price anything.

Request a pricing read

Work With Us

Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.