Prodigy Real Estate

Scotch Plains Home Sales, Fall 2026: What Sold, How Old It Was and How Big

Anthony Licciardello  |  November 21, 2026

Scotch Plains

Scotch Plains Home Sales, Fall 2026: What Sold, How Old It Was and How Big

Union County · Sales Ledger · Fall 2026 · Scotch Plains, NJ

Fifty closings in twelve weeks, a $2.66 million new build at the top, and a 1736 farmhouse in the middle of the list. Here is what actually sold in Scotch Plains this fall, how old each house was, and how much floor area the money bought.

50
Closings · Aug 26 to Nov 19
$2.66M
Top Sale · 6 Kevin Road
290 Yrs
Oldest to Newest · 1736 to 2026
16
Sales at $1 Million or More
The Argument in Brief
  • New construction took the two highest prices of the season. Both homes carry a 2026 build year and both replaced small mid-century houses.
  • Age did not cap price. A farmhouse dated 1736 closed at $1.35 million, and four homes built between 1953 and 1960 closed between $1.31 million and $1.695 million.
  • Bigger homes cost less per square foot. A new 4,200-square-foot colonial traded near $339 a foot while a 1,452-square-foot house traded near $481.
  • Five sales with a published list price closed a combined $645,000 or so above asking. The largest gap was $225,000 on a 1953 home on Dogwood Drive.

Scotch Plains closed out the fall with a wide tape. Between August 26 and November 19, 2026, the Garden State MLS feed recorded 50 closed sales at Scotch Plains addresses, worth about $44.6 million combined. The midpoint of that list sits at $732,500. Sixteen of the fifty closed above $1 million, five closed at $1.5 million or more, and fourteen closed under $600,000.

Those totals describe the mix. The individual houses tell you more. This ledger goes address by address and attaches the two facts buyers and sellers ask about first: when the house was built and how many square feet it holds. It picks up where our October 2026 Scotch Plains market update left off, and it adds to the record in our summer luxury sales ledger.

I
The Top of the Tape

Scotch Plains New Construction Took the Two Highest Prices of the Fall

Sale of the Season
6 Kevin Road
$2,660,000
Built 20266 Beds7 Baths0.92 AcreClosed Nov 17
The highest closing of fall 2026, on a lot that held a 2,021-square-foot house from 1963.

The highest sale of the season closed on November 17. Six Kevin Road sold for $2,660,000. The record shows a 2026 build year, six bedrooms and seven baths on a lot of roughly 0.92 acre. County property records for the same parcel describe what stood there before: a one-story 1963 house with 2,021 square feet of living area.

Three days earlier, 316 Acacia Road closed at $1,700,000. That home also carries a 2026 build year, with five bedrooms and six baths. The earlier house on that quarter-acre lot was a 1951 story-and-a-half with 1,260 square feet. Both sales were recorded with zero days on market, which usually means the buyer was in place before any public listing period began.

A third new build rounds out the group. On September 24, 1586 Front Street closed at $1,425,000. It is a five-bedroom colonial with a 2026 build year and 4,200 square feet on a lot of about 0.22 acre. It had been listed at $1,299,999. Public records show the property changing hands in June 2025 in the mid-$400,000s, before the new house went up.

🏗️ Before and After · Three Lots
6 Kevin Road
Before
1963
One-story house
2,021 sq ft
→
After
$2,660,000
Built 2026
6 beds, 7 baths
316 Acacia Road
Before
1951
Story-and-a-half
1,260 sq ft
→
After
$1,700,000
Built 2026
5 beds, 6 baths
1586 Front Street
Before
2025
Sold in June
Mid-$400,000s
→
After
$1,425,000
Built 2026
4,200 sq ft

The pattern is the one we traced in the Scotch Plains Top 10: the ceiling is being set by new homes on lots that used to hold much smaller ones. The full top tier for the fall is below.

New BuildContemporaryMid-CenturyHistoricTownhome
016 Kevin Rd
$2,660,000
New Build
Built
2026
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
6 / 7
Closed
Nov 17
02316 Acacia Rd
$1,700,000
New Build
Built
2026
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
5 / 6
Closed
Nov 14
033 Karen Ct
$1,695,000
Mid-Century
Built
1960
Sq Ft
3,802
Bd / Ba
5 / 5.5
Closed
Aug 31
041253 Maple Hill Rd
$1,600,000
Mid-Century
Built
1954
Sq Ft
3,433
Bd / Ba
4 / 3
Closed
Sep 24
05504 Tillinghast Turn
$1,500,000
ContemporaryTownhome
Built
2016
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
3 / 3.5
Closed
Oct 15
061586 Front St
$1,425,000
New Build
Built
2026
Sq Ft
4,200
Bd / Ba
5 / 3.5
Closed
Sep 24
071979 Dogwood Dr
$1,375,000
Mid-Century
Built
1953
Sq Ft
2,341
Bd / Ba
4 / 3.5
Closed
Sep 10
081230 Terrill Rd
$1,350,000
Historic
Built
1736
Sq Ft
4,283
Bd / Ba
7 / 4F 2H
Closed
Oct 1
0939 Highlander Dr
$1,310,000
Mid-Century
Built
1959
Sq Ft
3,181
Bd / Ba
4 / 3
Closed
Sep 14
101245 Sunnyfield Ln
$1,285,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
3,680
Bd / Ba
5 / 3
Closed
Oct 5
1131 Blackbirch Rd
$1,200,000
Contemporary
Built
1991
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
5 / 4.5
Closed
Nov 19
1218 Jacobs Ln
$1,140,500
Contemporary
Built
1996
Sq Ft
—
Bd / Ba
4 / 4
Closed
Sep 28
131680 Raritan Rd
$1,100,000
Contemporary
Built
2006
Sq Ft
2,904
Bd / Ba
5 / 4.5
Closed
Sep 24

All closings 2026. Bd / Ba is bedrooms and baths; 4F 2H means four full and two half baths. Square footage is the listing figure where one was published and the tax-record figure otherwise. A dash means the figure was not published.

II
Age of the Homes

A 1736 Farmhouse and Four Mid-Century Homes: What Age Did to Scotch Plains Prices

🕰️ 290 Years on One Tape · Fall 2026 Sales by Year Built
1736
Terrill Road farmhouse
$1,350,000
2026
Three new builds
up to $2,660,000
1750
1800
1850
1900
1950
2000
Historic, before 1940Mid-century, 1945 to 1969Contemporary, 1985 to 2016New build, 2026
Each dot is one fall 2026 closing, placed by the year the home was built. 24 sales with a build year on record.
1736
1230 Terrill Road
4,283 sq ft · 1.19 acres · sold $1,350,000

The oldest house on the tape is also one of the most interesting. The farmhouse at 1230 Terrill Road is dated 1736. It closed on October 1 at $1,350,000, about 4% over its $1,299,900 list price. The listing describes seven bedrooms, four full and two half baths, and 4,283 square feet on 1.19 acres in the Fox Lair section, with a renovation dated 2026. The same property sold for $525,000 in August 2020.

Then come the mid-century homes. Four houses built between 1953 and 1960 closed above $1.3 million this fall. Three Karen Court, built 1960 with 3,802 square feet on just over an acre, sold at its $1,695,000 asking price. The 1954 home at 1253 Maple Hill Road went for $1,600,000 after four days on the market. A 1953 home at 1979 Dogwood Drive brought $1,375,000. And 39 Highlander Drive, a 1959 home of 3,181 square feet on about an acre, closed at $1,310,000.

4 Days
1253 Maple Hill Road
Built 1954 · sold $1,600,000

What those four share is land and floor area. Each sits on a lot of more than half an acre, and each one with a size on record holds more than 2,300 square feet. Year built mattered less than what the house had become and what it sat on. We cover how style and era price out in our guide to colonials, split-levels and ranches in Scotch Plains.

Across the whole fall list, 24 sales have a build year on record. The spread shows how much of Scotch Plains was built in one generation.

🏡 When the Fall 2026 Homes Were Built · 24 Sales
1945 to 196910 sales
1985 to 20068 sales
2016 to 20264 sales
Before 19402 sales

Counts cover the 24 fall closings in this ledger with a build year in MLS or tax records.

III
Square Footage

Square Footage in Scotch Plains: Why the Biggest Homes Cost Less Per Foot

$339 / sq ft
1586 Front Street
New 2026 build · 4,200 sq ft

Price per square foot ran in the opposite direction from total price. The new 4,200-square-foot colonial on Front Street works out to about $339 a foot. The 1736 farmhouse, at 4,283 square feet, works out to about $315. The 3,680-square-foot home at 1245 Sunnyfield Lane comes to roughly $349.

Now look at the smaller houses. A 1,452-square-foot home at 2114 Aldene Avenue sold for $699,000, or $481 a foot. A 1969 home of 2,072 square feet at 869 O'Donnell Avenue sold for $900,000, or $434 a foot, after nine days on the market. A 1958 house of 1,380 square feet on William Street came in at $424.

Every house carries a lot, a kitchen, a heating system and a location, and those costs get spread over fewer feet in a small home. For a seller, that means a per-foot number borrowed from a larger house will underprice a smaller one, and the reverse will overprice a big one.

📐 Price Per Square Foot · Ten Fall 2026 Closings
2114 Aldene Ave · 1,452 sq ft$481
869 O'Donnell Ave · 2,072 sq ft$434
305 William St · 1,380 sq ft$424
2402 Hamlette Pl · 1,807 sq ft$415
39 Highlander Dr · 3,181 sq ft$412
1680 Raritan Rd · 2,904 sq ft$379
1245 Sunnyfield Ln · 3,680 sq ft$349
1586 Front St · 4,200 sq ft$339
1230 Terrill Rd · 4,283 sq ft$315
40 Wareham Ct · 2,016 sq ft · townhome$303

Dark bars are detached homes under 2,100 sq ft. Each figure is the closed price divided by the published square footage.

🚩
Read Square Footage With Care

Square footage comes from two places, and they do not always agree. A listing figure is supplied by the listing side and can include finished space the assessor never counted. A tax-record figure can lag behind an addition or a renovation. The Terrill Road farmhouse is the clearest case: 4,283 square feet in the listing and 2,984 in the tax record. Before you compare two homes by price per foot, confirm both are measured the same way.

For Scotch Plains Sellers
Which of these sales is the right comparison for your house?

Age, lot and floor area decide that, and the answer changes street by street. We will line your home up against the closings that actually match it.

Get Your Home Value →

IV
List Price Versus Sold Price

Over Asking in Scotch Plains: Five Sales, About $645,000 Above List

+$225,000
1979 Dogwood Drive
Listed $1,150,000 · sold $1,375,000

Six of the top-tier sales have a published list price to compare against. One closed at its asking price. The other five closed above it, by a combined total of about $645,000.

The widest gap belongs to 1979 Dogwood Drive. The 1953 home on 0.59 acre was listed at $1,150,000 and closed at $1,375,000, nearly 20% higher. It last sold in 2016 for $681,000. The townhome at 504 Tillinghast Turn, built in 2016, was listed at $1,360,000 and closed at $1,500,000 after 15 days. That is well above where most attached homes in town traded this fall.

The home at 1245 Sunnyfield Lane, on nearly an acre, was listed at $1,180,000 and closed at $1,285,000. For the longer record on that street, see our address-by-address look at Cooper Road and Sunnyfield Lane.

📈 Dollars Over List Price · Fall 2026
1979 Dogwood Dr · built 1953+$225,000
504 Tillinghast Turn · built 2016+$140,000
1586 Front St · built 2026+$125,000
1245 Sunnyfield Ln · 3,680 sq ft+$105,000
1230 Terrill Rd · built 1736+$50,100

Closed price minus the last published list price. 3 Karen Court closed at its $1,695,000 list price and is not charted.

The lesson for sellers is in the list prices. Each of these homes came to market below where it ended up, and competing buyers closed the gap. We lay out that pricing logic in the Scotch Plains seller's playbook.

V
Under $1 Million

The Scotch Plains Middle and Entry Tape: Older Houses, Smaller Footprints, Faster Sales

6 Days
1133 Hetfield Avenue
Built 1950 · sold $525,000

Thirty-four of the fifty closings came in under $1 million, and this is where most Scotch Plains buyers actually shop. The single-family homes in this band are mostly from the 1940s through the 1960s, with footprints between roughly 1,400 and 2,100 square feet.

The well-priced ones moved quickly. The 1950 home at 1133 Hetfield Avenue sold for $525,000 in six days. The 1969 home on O'Donnell Avenue took nine. A 1966 four-bedroom at 2527 Mountain Avenue sold for $735,000 in thirteen days, and a 1945 home at 2094 Westfield Road Circle brought $851,500 in fourteen.

Townhomes and condos took longer. The 2004 units on Donato Circle closed at $520,000 and $549,000 after 79 and 46 days. A 1985 townhome of 2,016 square feet at 40 Wareham Court sold for $610,000 after 49 days. That is a lot of floor area for the money, at about $303 a foot, and a reminder that attached homes price on a different scale than detached ones.

869 O'Donnell Ave
$900,000
Mid-Century
Built
1969
Sq Ft
2,072
Days
9
Closed
Aug 28
2094 Westfield Road Cir
$851,500
Mid-Century
Built
1945
Sq Ft
—
Days
14
Closed
Sep 16
2402 Hamlette Pl
$750,000
Contemporary
Built
1992
Sq Ft
1,807
Days
26
Closed
Sep 14
2527 Mountain Ave
$735,000
Mid-Century
Built
1966
Sq Ft
—
Days
13
Closed
Oct 23
2114 Aldene Ave
$699,000
Built
—
Sq Ft
1,452
Days
22
Closed
Oct 26
40 Wareham Ct
$610,000
ContemporaryTownhome
Built
1985
Sq Ft
2,016
Days
49
Closed
Oct 15
2081 Coles Ave
$590,000
Mid-Century
Built
1949
Sq Ft
1,530
Days
17
Closed
Sep 11
305 William St
$585,000
Mid-Century
Built
1958
Sq Ft
1,380
Days
48
Closed
Oct 26
2104 Westfield Ave
$580,000
Historic
Built
1920
Sq Ft
—
Days
42
Closed
Nov 12
118 Donato Cir
$549,000
ContemporaryTownhome
Built
2004
Sq Ft
—
Days
46
Closed
Sep 25
1133 Hetfield Ave
$525,000
Mid-Century
Built
1950
Sq Ft
—
Days
6
Closed
Sep 3
605 Donato Cir
$520,000
ContemporaryTownhome
Built
2004
Sq Ft
1,758
Days
79
Closed
Nov 9
2219 North Ave, Unit 14
$515,000
ContemporaryTownhome
Built
1985
Sq Ft
1,420
Days
26
Closed
Aug 26

All closings 2026. Days is days on market as reported with the closed listing. A dash means the figure was not published.

If you are weighing where in town these homes sit, our piece on the Scotch Plains north and south sides explains why two houses of the same age and size can sell far apart. Current listings are on our Scotch Plains homes for sale page.

💡
Insider Tip

If your Scotch Plains house is a 1950s or 1960s original on a lot of half an acre or more, get two numbers before you list: what it is worth to a family who will live in it, and what the land is worth to someone who will build. This fall, small mid-century houses on Kevin Road and Acacia Road became $2.66 million and $1.7 million new builds. The gap between those two values is yours to negotiate, and only if you know it exists.

Broker's Note

"People worry that an old house is a hard sell. This fall a farmhouse older than the country sold for $1.35 million. Buyers pay for a home that has been cared for, on land that is worth having. The year on the deed is the smallest part of it."

Anthony Licciardello, Broker, The Prodigy Team

Anthony Licciardello
Broker, The Prodigy Team

Anthony Licciardello, Broker, The Prodigy Team

The Prodigy Team Advantage
Why the Buyer for Your Scotch Plains Home May Be Coming From New York
Two decades in the business
5,000+ closed transactions
Dual New York and New Jersey broker licenses
Former Director of Community Affairs, Bloomberg Administration
Member, Staten Island Growth Management Task Force

A meaningful share of Union County demand starts across the bridge. The Prodigy Team is licensed on both sides, so we work with New York buyers before they ever tour a New Jersey home. Our digital reach is built for that pipeline: a YouTube channel with more than 400,000 views over the past year, a relocation community of more than 26,500 members on Facebook, and more than 17 million impressions on Pinterest.

Our in-house aerial series, Above the Streets, shows a home in the context buyers care about: the lot, the block and the town around it.

Thinking About Selling in Scotch Plains?
Find out where your home sits on this fall's tape.

Call 718-873-7345 or start with a home value review.

See Why Clients Choose Us

Scotch Plains Home Sales, Fall 2026: Questions and Answers

Top Sale

What was the most expensive home sold in Scotch Plains in fall 2026?

6 Kevin Road, which closed on November 17, 2026 at $2,660,000. It is recorded as a 2026-built home with six bedrooms and seven baths on about 0.92 acre.

Age

How old are the homes that sold in Scotch Plains this fall?

They range from 1736 to 2026. Of the 24 fall closings in this ledger with a build year on record, ten were built between 1945 and 1969, eight between 1985 and 2006, four between 2016 and 2026, and two before 1940.

Price Per Foot

What did Scotch Plains homes sell for per square foot?

Among ten fall closings with published square footage, the range ran from about $303 to $481 per square foot. Detached homes under 2,100 square feet sold between $415 and $481 a foot. Homes over 3,600 square feet sold between about $315 and $349.

Over Asking

Are Scotch Plains homes still selling over asking price?

Some are. Of six top-tier fall sales with a published list price, five closed above it and one closed at it. The largest gap was 1979 Dogwood Drive, listed at $1,150,000 and sold at $1,375,000.

Townhomes

What do townhomes sell for in Scotch Plains?

Fall closings on the township's townhome and condo streets ran from roughly $420,000 to $610,000, including units on Donato Circle, Wareham Court and North Avenue. The exception was 504 Tillinghast Turn, a 2016 townhome that closed at $1,500,000.

🗺️ Explore Nearby · Union County
  • See what is listed next door in Fanwood, which shares the Scotch Plains-Fanwood schools.
  • Compare the price tiers in Westfield.
  • Look at the wooded lots of Mountainside.
  • Browse homes in neighboring Clark.

Sources and data notes. Closed sale prices and dates: Garden State Multiple Listing Service closed-sale records as displayed by Movoto and Homes.com, retrieved November 21, 2026, covering 50 closings at Scotch Plains addresses from August 26 through November 19, 2026. Build years, bedroom and bath counts, days on market, list prices and listing square footage: GSMLS listing records as displayed by Homes.com, Trulia and participating IDX sites. Tax-record square footage, lot sizes and prior sale history: Union County property records as displayed by NJParcels, PropertyShark and Redfin. Price-per-square-foot figures are the closed price divided by published square footage. Totals, midpoints and counts are calculated from this ledger and describe these 50 closings only; they are not a township-wide median. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Work With Us

Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.