Homes for sale in Shrewsbury Borough, NJ — current 07702 listings, median sale prices near $950K, the Historic Four Corners colonial district, the Red Bank Regional High School district, and The Grove at Shrewsbury outdoor mall.
A historic Two River borough with the 1769 Christ Church. The Four Corners, the Broad Street shops, and colonial heritage at the center of the Two River area.
Shrewsbury is one of Monmouth County's oldest and most historic communities — a small, affluent 2.16-square-mile borough of 4,184 residents (2020) at the crossroads of the Two River area. Its Historic Four Corners, the landmark Christ Church of 1769, and the colonial-era Allen House anchor a borough that pairs deep heritage with an enviably central, convenient location.
The median sale runs near $950K, across classic colonials, updated homes, and properties near the historic core. The Broad Street corridor and The Grove offer upscale shopping, the Little Silver train station and Red Bank are minutes away, and students attend the Shrewsbury Borough School and the highly regarded Red Bank Regional High School. Run under a borough government, Shrewsbury blends history, prestige, and easy access to everything in the Two River area.
Shrewsbury draws buyers who want historic character and a central Two River location with excellent schools and upscale shopping at the doorstep. Its blend of heritage and convenience makes it one of the area's most distinctive small boroughs.
The Four Corners, Christ Church of 1769, and the Allen House give Shrewsbury a sense of place few communities can match.
Minutes from Red Bank, the Little Silver train, and the Parkway, with Broad Street shopping and The Grove right in town.
Red Bank Regional High School, one of New Jersey's most respected, serves the borough alongside its own elementary school.
An upscale market of colonials, historic homes, and updated properties.
Larger colonials, new construction, and homes near the historic core on the borough's most desirable streets.
Comparable to: Fair Haven, Little Silver upper.
Classic colonials and updated homes across the borough's established streets — the heart of the market.
Comparable to: Little Silver, Red Bank upper.
Smaller homes, townhomes, and condos — the entry point into the borough and its top regional school.
Comparable to: Red Bank, Eatontown.
A small borough organized around its historic core:
The colonial heart of the borough — Christ Church, the Allen House, and historic homes around the landmark intersection.
The commercial spine and upscale shopping at The Grove — convenience and walkability near the borough's retail core.
A sought-after residential neighborhood of established homes — quiet, family-friendly streets within the borough.
The western residential blocks near the borough's parkland — convenient, settled neighborhoods toward the Parkway side.
The eastern blocks toward Little Silver — close to the train station and the wider Two River area.
"Shrewsbury is one of Monmouth County's oldest communities — a small, affluent 2.16-square-mile borough of 4,184 at the crossroads of the Two River area. Its Historic Four Corners, the landmark Christ Church of 1769, and the colonial Allen House anchor a borough that pairs deep heritage with an enviably central location. With a median near $950K and a top regional school, it blends history, prestige, and convenience."
Shrewsbury cross-shops with Little Silver, Red Bank, Fair Haven, and Oceanport.
Town | Median | Population | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
Shrewsbury ★ | $950,000 | 4,184 | 2.16 mi² |
$1,000,000 | 6,131 | 2.7 mi² | |
$685,000 | 12,936 | 1.75 mi² | |
$1,400,000 | 6,269 | 1.59 mi² | |
$1,200,000 | 6,150 | 3.17 mi² |
★ Subject borough. Sources: Monmouth County government; U.S. Census. Shrewsbury Borough population 4,184 (2020 census); 2.16 sq mi land in the Two River area; one of Monmouth's oldest communities, home to the Historic Four Corners, Christ Church (1769), and the colonial Allen House, with Broad Street shopping and The Grove, minutes from the Little Silver train station and Red Bank; served by the Shrewsbury Borough School and Red Bank Regional High School; a borough government; median sale price approximately $950,000. Comparison figures approximate. Verify property-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
Heritage You Can See. Few towns wear their history as visibly as Shrewsbury, where Christ Church and the Allen House sit at the everyday center of the borough.
A Central Crossroads. Shrewsbury's position puts Red Bank, the train, the Parkway, and the shore all within minutes — convenience is built into the address.
Shopping at the Doorstep. Broad Street and The Grove give the borough upscale retail and dining that draw from across the Two River area.
A Coveted Regional School. Access to Red Bank Regional High School adds real, lasting value for families choosing the borough.
Schools + Government. The Shrewsbury Borough School (K-8) and Red Bank Regional High School serve the borough under a borough government.
Around $950K. Larger and new homes run $1.3M-$2M+, the core market $750K-$1.3M, and smaller homes and condos $575K-$750K.
Its colonial history — the Historic Four Corners, Christ Church of 1769, and the Allen House — plus Broad Street shopping and The Grove.
Not its own, but the NJ Transit station in adjacent Little Silver, on the North Jersey Coast Line, is just minutes away.
The Shrewsbury Borough School (K-8), with high schoolers attending Red Bank Regional High School, shared with Red Bank and Little Silver.
NY + NJ licensed · cinematic 4K drone marketing · historic-borough & Two River specialists.
Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.