Homes for sale in Neptune City, NJ — current 07753 listings, median sale prices, the substantial 0.61 mi² Monmouth County borough surrounded by Neptune Township + Avon-by-the-Sea — substantial K-8 own Woodrow Wilson Elementary + 9-12 Neptune HS Scarlet Fliers sending, substantial Main Street commercial corridor, substantial Shark River Hills + Shark River Inlet proximity, substantial walkable to Asbury Park + Avon-by-the-Sea Atlantic Ocean beaches, and substantial preserved small-borough Jersey Shore residential character.
If you're searching for homes for sale in Neptune City, NJ, you're looking at the substantial small Jersey Shore borough in Monmouth County — a 0.90-square-mile borough of 4,626 residents (2020, -5.0% from 4,869 in 2010, est. 4,581 in 2023) named after Neptune, the Roman water deity, reflecting the borough's location near the Atlantic Ocean. The Borough of Neptune City was incorporated on October 4, 1881, based on a referendum held on March 19, 1881. The substantial original boundaries included all of present-day Neptune City PLUS what is now Avon-by-the-Sea and the southern portion of Bradley Beach. On March 23, 1900, the substantial Borough of Avon-by-the-Sea was created from Neptune City; on March 13, 1907, the eastern portion of Neptune City was annexed to the Borough of Bradley Beach. The substantial Neptune City School District operates K-8 own (Woodrow Wilson School at 210 West Sylvania Avenue, 272 students 2022-23, 9.4:1 ratio, DFG CD); 9-12 students attend Neptune High School in Neptune Township as part of a sending/receiving relationship. Neptune City real estate trades at a median sale price near $530,000-$567,000 (Homes.com May 2025 median $530K; Redfin November 2025 median $567K +42.5% YoY; Rocket Homes December 2024 median $490K +5.3% YoY). Borders Bradley Beach (E), Avon-by-the-Sea (S), and Neptune Township (N, W). Substantial Lake Sylvan + Shark River waterfront character.
Neptune City is the rare substantial 0.90-square-mile Jersey Shore Monmouth borough that delivers substantial Lake Sylvan + Shark River waterfront character, substantial walkability (most streets have sidewalks), substantial K-8 own Neptune City School District (Woodrow Wilson School, 272 students, 9.4:1 ratio), substantial Neptune HS (Neptune Township) sending, substantial Monmouth County Vocational School District Academy access (MAST Sandy Hook, High Technology HS in Lincroft, Academy of Allied Health & Science in Neptune Township, Communications HS in Wall Township, Biotechnology HS in Freehold Township), substantial Red Bank Regional HS Performing Arts Program access (Little Silver), substantial Cape Cod + Colonial-style historic housing inventory from the 1960s, substantial recent newer construction with substantial Lake Sylvan-frontage residences priced from $1,099,000, substantial proximity to Atlantic Ocean beaches (Avon-by-the-Sea + Bradley Beach immediately adjacent), and substantial Belmar Marina nearby. The substantial Borough of Neptune City was incorporated on October 4, 1881, based on a referendum held on March 19, 1881. The substantial original boundaries included all of present-day Neptune City PLUS what is now Avon-by-the-Sea and the southern portion of Bradley Beach. On March 23, 1900, the substantial Borough of Avon-by-the-Sea was created from Neptune City. On March 13, 1907, the eastern portion of Neptune City was annexed to the Borough of Bradley Beach. The borough was named after Neptune, the Roman water deity, reflecting the substantial borough's location on the Atlantic Ocean. Mayor: Rachel McGreevy (D, term ends December 31, 2027); Administrator Al Jardine; Municipal Clerk Corinne DiCorcia Williams. Population 4,626 (2020), est. 4,581 in 2023, -5.0% from 4,869 in 2010. Density 5,162.1/sq mi (111th of 565 in state, 12th of 53 in county — substantial high-density borough). Elevation 23 ft. The substantial 0.90 sq mi total area (516th of 565 in state by area, 43rd of 53 in county); all 0.90 sq mi is land (0% water). ZIP code 07753.
Neptune City School District operates a substantial K-8 own community public school district with 1 school — Woodrow Wilson School at 210 West Sylvania Avenue, Neptune City 07753. Enrollment 272 students 2022-23, 29.0 FTE faculty, 9.4:1 ratio. Superintendent: Raymond J. Boccuti. Business administrator: Mindy Green. DFG CD. The substantial single school building serves substantial K-8 students from all the area within the municipal boundaries of the borough of Neptune City. Substantial 9.4:1 student-teacher ratio is substantially better than typical districts. Substantial recent feasibility study analyzed substantial educational, fiscal and organizational options.
For high school (grades 9-12), Neptune City students attend Neptune High School in Neptune Township as part of a substantial sending/receiving relationship with the Neptune Township Schools. Substantial students from Neptune City can also attend one of the 5 substantial Monmouth County Vocational School District Academies: The Marine Academy of Science and Technology (MAST) on Sandy Hook, High Technology High School in Lincroft, The Academy of Allied Health & Science in Neptune Township (connected to Jersey Shore Medical Center), Communications High School in Wall Township, and Biotechnology High School in Freehold Township. Substantial Red Bank Regional HS Performing Arts Program access in Little Silver (also has Academies for Information Technology and Finance).
The substantial Lake Sylvan — substantial scenic lake at the heart of Neptune City — anchors substantial waterfront residential character with substantial 6-block proximity to the Atlantic Ocean. Substantial newer construction residences (priced from $1,099,000) feature substantial serene water views from every room and substantial direct lake-frontage. The substantial Shark River runs along the substantial northern Neptune City border, providing substantial additional waterfront character. Substantial walkability (most streets have sidewalks). Substantial proximity to Atlantic Ocean beaches via adjacent Avon-by-the-Sea + Bradley Beach + Belmar Marina nearby.
Neptune City's housing stock concentrates in substantial mix of Colonial-style homes (popular across NJ) and substantial Cape Cod bungalows from the 1960s lining nearly every street (substantial Jersey Shore beach-community heritage), plus substantial newer Lake Sylvan-frontage construction (priced from $1,099,000). Median sale prices: Redfin November 2025 median sale $567,000 (+42.5% YoY, $482/sqft +38.1% YoY, 15.5-day DOM, "most competitive" Redfin Compete Score 94 — homes sell ~2% above list, hot homes ~8% above list in 12 days); Homes.com May 2025 median home price $530,000 (12-month median sale $527,500 +15% YoY, average sale $491,479, 29-day DOM, 7 houses for sale, prices $425K-$1,075K); Rocket Homes December 2024 median sold $490,000 (+5.3% YoY, $379/sqft, 6-day average DOM, listings down 67% YoY); Movoto May 2026 median list $625,000 (13-day DOM). The substantial competitive market reflects substantial scarcity — many homes get multiple offers, often with waived contingencies. Median home prices substantially in line with Monmouth County standards, yet substantially more inexpensive than nearby Deal and Bradley Beach.
Substantial Cape Cod bungalows (from the 1960s, lining nearly every street) and substantial smaller Colonial-style single-family residences. The most accessible Neptune City entry point — substantial first-time and primary-residence buyers seeking the substantial Jersey Shore beach-community character at substantially more accessible pricing than neighboring Deal and Bradley Beach. The Rocket Homes December 2024 median sale $490,000 and Homes.com prices starting $425,000 anchor this tier.
Substantial larger Colonial-style and substantially updated single-family residences throughout Neptune City's substantial primary residential blocks. The largest segment by transaction volume — substantial primary-residence year-round families anchored by the substantial K-8 own Neptune City School District + 9-12 Neptune HS (Neptune Township) sending. The Redfin November 2025 median sale $567,000 and Movoto May 2026 median list $625,000 anchor this tier. Substantial 15.5-day DOM reflects substantial competitive market.
Substantial newer Lake Sylvan-frontage construction (priced from $1,099,000) with substantial 3-bedroom, 4-bath, 2,700 sqft floor plans, substantial attached garages, substantial bonus lofts, and substantial serene water views from every room. Premium End Unit townhomes available with substantial limited-time builder incentives (one year prepaid HOA fee). Among the most-distinctive Lake Sylvan-frontage / Atlantic-Ocean-block residential inventory, with substantial primary-residence demand from substantial discerning property buyers seeking substantial newer construction in walking distance of substantial beaches.
Neptune City's compact 0.90-square-mile borough segments by proximity to the substantial Sylvania Avenue civic spine (anchored by Woodrow Wilson School at 210 West Sylvania Avenue), the substantial Lake Sylvan waterfront pocket (substantial newer construction), the substantial Shark River northern border, the substantial Bradley Beach / Avon-by-the-Sea border eastern Neptune City pocket, and the substantial Neptune Township border northern / western Neptune City residential pockets.
The substantial Sylvania Avenue civic spine — substantial center of Neptune City. Substantial Woodrow Wilson School at 210 West Sylvania Avenue (K-8, 272 students, Superintendent Raymond J. Boccuti). Substantial single-family Colonial-style and Cape Cod residential inventory along the substantial corridor. Substantial walkability (most streets have sidewalks). Substantial primary-residence families substantially anchored by substantial walking-distance proximity to the borough's only school.
The substantial Lake Sylvan waterfront pocket — substantial newer construction residences (priced from $1,099,000) feature substantial direct Lake Sylvan-frontage and substantial 6-block proximity to the Atlantic Ocean. Substantial 3-bedroom, 4-bath, 2,700 sqft floor plans with substantial attached garages and substantial bonus lofts. Substantial serene water views from every room. Among the most-watched Neptune City residential pockets, with substantial newer-construction premium pricing.
The substantial Shark River northern border pocket. Substantial waterfront character along the substantial Shark River. Substantial residential blocks adjacent to substantial preserved natural shoreline. Substantial nearby Belmar Marina across the substantial Shark River provides substantial substantial boating and marine character. Substantial single-family Cape Cod and Colonial-style residential inventory.
The substantial eastern Neptune City pocket bordering Bradley Beach and Avon-by-the-Sea. Substantial walking-distance proximity to substantial Atlantic Ocean beaches via Avon-by-the-Sea and Bradley Beach (substantial historical boundaries — Bradley Beach was annexed eastern Neptune City portion in 1907; Avon-by-the-Sea was created from Neptune City in 1900). Substantial single-family Colonial-style residential inventory commands substantial premium pricing for substantial beach-block adjacency.
The substantial western Neptune City pocket bordering Neptune Township on all interior sides. Substantial single-family Cape Cod (1960s) and Colonial-style residential inventory. Among the more accessible primary-residence Neptune City pockets relative to the substantial Lake Sylvan waterfront residential blocks. Substantial primary-residence year-round families anchor substantial residential continuity along the substantial Neptune City-Neptune Township border.
"Neptune City is the rare 0.90-square-mile Jersey Shore Monmouth borough named after Neptune, the Roman water deity — incorporated October 4, 1881, with original boundaries that included present-day Avon-by-the-Sea and southern Bradley Beach. With substantial Lake Sylvan + Shark River waterfront character, K-8 own Neptune City School District (Woodrow Wilson School, 272 students, 9.4:1) + 9-12 Neptune HS (Neptune Township) sending, substantial 5 Monmouth County Vocational School District Academies access, Cape Cod bungalows lining nearly every street from the 1960s, and median home sales $530K-$567K (+42.5% YoY Redfin Nov 2025) with newer Lake Sylvan-frontage construction from $1.099M, Neptune City is among the substantial most-distinctive small Jersey Shore boroughs in Monmouth County."
Neptune City cross-shops most directly with Avon-by-the-Sea (immediately south, substantial Atlantic Ocean beach-block borough, substantially higher pricing, created from Neptune City in 1900), Bradley Beach (immediately east, substantial Atlantic Ocean beach-block borough, substantially higher pricing, annexed eastern Neptune City portion in 1907), Neptune Township (substantially larger township that entirely surrounds Neptune City on N/W sides, same Neptune HS), and Belmar (immediately south across Shark River, substantial Atlantic Ocean beach borough).
| Town | Median Sale | Avg. Tax | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
| Neptune City ★ | $567,000 | $10,200 | 0.90 mi² |
| Avon-by-the-Sea | $1,365,000 | $11,400 | 0.4 mi² |
| Bradley Beach | $815,000 | $9,200 | 0.6 mi² |
| Neptune Township | $590,000 | $9,600 | 8.5 mi² |
| Belmar | $1,150,000 | $10,900 | 1 mi² |
★ Subject town. Sources: Monmouth County Board of Taxation (2025 certified data), Neptune City School District (K-8 own, Woodrow Wilson School at 210 West Sylvania Avenue, 272 students 2022-23, 9.4:1 ratio, DFG CD, Superintendent Raymond J. Boccuti); 9-12 Neptune HS (Neptune Township) sending; Redfin November 2025 median sale $567,000 (+42.5% YoY, $482/sqft, 15.5-day DOM, Compete Score 94 "most competitive"); Homes.com May 2025 median home price $530,000; Rocket Homes December 2024 median sold $490,000 (+5.3% YoY); Movoto May 2026 median list $625,000. Neptune City pricing varies substantially by section — verify section-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
Borough History & Neptune Roman Water Deity. The Borough of Neptune City was incorporated on October 4, 1881, based on a referendum held on March 19, 1881. The substantial original boundaries included all of present-day Neptune City PLUS what is now Avon-by-the-Sea and the southern portion of Bradley Beach. On March 23, 1900, a bill approved in the New Jersey Legislature created the Borough of Avon-by-the-Sea from Neptune City. On March 13, 1907, the eastern portion of Neptune City was annexed to the Borough of Bradley Beach. The borough was named after Neptune, the Roman water deity, reflecting the substantial borough's location on the Atlantic Ocean. Substantial first factory in Neptune City was the Steiner and Son's Pajama Factory, built in 1891. Mayor: Rachel McGreevy (D, term ends December 31, 2027); Administrator Al Jardine; Municipal Clerk Corinne DiCorcia Williams. Population 4,626 (2020), est. 4,581 in 2023, -5.0% from 4,869 in 2010 (with 2,133 households + 1,220 families per 2010 census). Density 5,162.1/sq mi (111th of 565 in state, 12th of 53 in county). Elevation 23 ft. Total area 0.90 sq mi (516th of 565 in state by area, 43rd of 53 in county); all 0.90 sq mi is land. ZIP code 07753.
Neptune City School District & Vocational Academy Access. Neptune City operates the substantial Neptune City School District (K-8 own with 1 school — Woodrow Wilson School at 210 West Sylvania Avenue, Neptune City 07753). Enrollment 272 students 2022-23, 29.0 FTE faculty, 9.4:1 ratio. Superintendent: Raymond J. Boccuti. Business administrator: Mindy Green. DFG CD. For high school (9-12), students attend Neptune High School in Neptune Township as part of a sending/receiving relationship with the Neptune Township Schools. Substantial students from Neptune City can also attend one of the 5 substantial Monmouth County Vocational School District Academies: The Marine Academy of Science and Technology (MAST) on Sandy Hook; High Technology High School in Lincroft; The Academy of Allied Health & Science in Neptune Township (connected to Jersey Shore Medical Center); Communications High School in Wall Township; and Biotechnology High School in Freehold Township. Substantial Red Bank Regional HS Performing Arts Program access in Little Silver (also has Academies for Information Technology and Finance).
Lake Sylvan + Shark River + Beach Access. The substantial Lake Sylvan — substantial scenic lake at the heart of Neptune City — anchors substantial waterfront residential character with substantial 6-block proximity to the Atlantic Ocean. Substantial newer construction residences (priced from $1,099,000) feature substantial 3-bedroom, 4-bath, 2,700 sqft floor plans with substantial attached garages, bonus lofts, and substantial serene water views from every room. The substantial Shark River runs along the substantial northern Neptune City border. Substantial Belmar Marina nearby across the substantial Shark River. The substantial nearby beaches of Avon-by-the-Sea and Bradley Beach are substantially walkable. Substantial walkability throughout the borough (most streets have sidewalks). The substantial recreation department offers a substantial recreation center with gym, game room, exercise room, computer room, TV room, and substantial special occasion room. Substantial activities include basketball, tennis, baseball, soccer, summer program.
Demographics, Economics & Transportation. Population 4,626 (2020), with substantial 5,162.1/sq mi density. Niche: substantial urban-suburban mix feel, most residents own their homes, substantial many young professionals, substantial conservative tendency, substantial highly rated public schools, substantial lots of bars and restaurants. Substantial 350 ranked city in NJ Livability (areavibes), ranked better than 62% of areas. Substantial higher than average median household income, income per capita and substantial lower unemployment rates. Substantial favorable home affordability ratio. Substantial good air quality and substantial nearby health facilities (Jersey Shore Medical Center in Neptune Township). Substantial cost of living 17% higher than national average per Redfin. Median home prices substantial 6.3% lower than the New Jersey average per areavibes. Substantial close proximity to local beaches and Belmar Marina. Substantial shops, restaurants, and local businesses. Substantial NJ Transit Bradley Beach train station nearby (NJCL).
The median sale price in Neptune City tracks at approximately $567,000 per Redfin November 2025 data (+42.5% YoY, $482/sqft +38.1% YoY, 15.5-day DOM, "most competitive" Redfin Compete Score 94 — homes sell ~2% above list, hot homes ~8% above list in 12 days). Homes.com May 2025 median home price $530,000 (12-month median sale $527,500 +15% YoY, prices $425K-$1,075K). Rocket Homes December 2024 median sold $490,000 (+5.3% YoY, $379/sqft, 6-day average DOM). Movoto May 2026 median list $625,000 (13-day DOM). Average tax bill approximately $10,200. The substantial competitive market reflects substantial scarcity — many homes get multiple offers, often with waived contingencies.
Neptune City operates the substantial Neptune City School District (K-8 own with 1 school — Woodrow Wilson School at 210 West Sylvania Avenue, 272 students 2022-23, 9.4:1 ratio, DFG CD, Superintendent Raymond J. Boccuti). For high school (9-12), Neptune City students attend Neptune High School in Neptune Township as part of a sending/receiving relationship with the Neptune Township Schools. Substantial students from Neptune City can also attend one of the 5 substantial Monmouth County Vocational School District Academies: MAST on Sandy Hook, High Technology HS in Lincroft, Academy of Allied Health & Science in Neptune Township, Communications HS in Wall Township, and Biotechnology HS in Freehold Township. Plus Red Bank Regional HS Performing Arts Program access in Little Silver.
The borough was named after Neptune, the Roman water deity, reflecting the substantial borough's location on the Atlantic Ocean. The substantial Borough of Neptune City was incorporated on October 4, 1881, based on a referendum held on March 19, 1881. The substantial original boundaries included all of present-day Neptune City PLUS what is now Avon-by-the-Sea and the southern portion of Bradley Beach. On March 23, 1900, the Borough of Avon-by-the-Sea was created from Neptune City. On March 13, 1907, the eastern portion of Neptune City was annexed to the Borough of Bradley Beach. The substantial Lake Sylvan + Shark River + Atlantic Ocean proximity continues the substantial water-themed character of the borough.
No — Neptune City and Neptune Township are substantial separate municipalities in Monmouth County. Neptune City is a substantial 0.90-square-mile borough (pop 4,626) that was substantially separated from Neptune Township in 1881. Neptune Township is a substantial 8.5-square-mile township (pop ~28,061) that entirely surrounds Neptune City on the N and W sides. The substantial Neptune Township includes substantial Ocean Grove historic village and Jersey Shore Medical Center. Neptune City has its own K-8 school district (Woodrow Wilson School) and shares a sending/receiving relationship with Neptune Township for grades 9-12 (Neptune HS). Both municipalities were named after Neptune, the Roman water deity.
The Prodigy Team works the Sylvania Avenue civic spine (anchored by Woodrow Wilson School at 210 West Sylvania Avenue), the Lake Sylvan waterfront pocket (newer construction from $1.099M), the Shark River northern border, the Bradley Beach / Avon-by-the-Sea border eastern pocket, and the Neptune Township border western residential pockets every week. Cinematic 4K aerial drone marketing — particularly valuable for Neptune City's substantial Cape Cod bungalows from the 1960s, Colonial-style residences, and substantial newer Lake Sylvan-frontage construction context — NYS/NJ broker representation, and 20+ years of Monmouth County transactional experience.
Contact The Prodigy TeamProdigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.