Homes for sale in Interlaken, NJ — current 07712 listings, median sale prices, the substantial 0.39 mi² inland Monmouth County borough between Asbury Park and Deal Lake with substantial Deal Lake + Lake Whalepond + Sunset Lake waterfront character, K-8 sending to Asbury Park + 9-12 sending to Asbury Park HS, substantial Bendermere Avenue + Grassmere Avenue residential corridors, substantial Wesley Lake nearby, and substantial preserved early 20th century lake-community character.
A tiny lakeside borough wrapped by the arms of Deal Lake. An exclusive enclave of estate homes between the northern and southern arms of Deal Lake — its name means "between the lakes."
Interlaken is one of the northern shore's hidden gems — a tiny 0.36-square-mile borough of about 900 residents (2020) almost entirely surrounded by the two arms of Deal Lake. Its very name, "between the lakes," describes its setting: a quiet, leafy enclave of estate homes tucked between Allenhurst, Asbury Park, and the water, just a short distance from the beaches.
The median sale runs near $1.37M, across gracious homes along Interlaken Drive, Windermere Avenue, and the lakefront. The borough is known for its winding streets, mature trees, and water frontage on both arms of Deal Lake, and its students attend area schools through sending relationships. Run under a borough government, Interlaken offers privacy, character, and a lakeside setting minutes from the ocean.
Interlaken draws buyers who want a quiet, estate-scale enclave with water on nearly every side, minutes from the ocean. Its lakeside setting, mature streets, and scarcity make it one of the northern shore's most coveted small markets.
The two arms of Deal Lake nearly surround the borough — its name, "between the lakes," says it all.
Gracious homes on winding, tree-lined streets give Interlaken a settled, estate-scale feel rare in such a small footprint.
Private and peaceful, yet minutes from Asbury Park, Allenhurst, and the beaches — seclusion without isolation.
A small, high-value market of lakeside estate homes.
The grandest estate homes along Windermere and the lakefront — the borough's most prized and largest properties.
Comparable to: Allenhurst, Deal entry.
Gracious homes across the borough's interior streets and lake frontage — the heart of the Interlaken market.
Comparable to: Loch Arbour, Allenhurst.
Smaller homes in western Interlaken — the most attainable, and rarest, way into this lakeside enclave.
Comparable to: Ocean Township upper, Asbury Park upper.
A small borough defined by the lake arms that surround it:
The northern lakefront bordering Allenhurst — water-facing homes on one of Deal Lake's quiet arms.
The southern lakefront toward Asbury Park — scenic homes along the borough's other water boundary.
The main corridor through the borough — the through-route connecting Interlaken to its neighbors.
The borough's signature estate streets — its grandest homes on winding, tree-lined avenues.
The western blocks of the borough — more attainable homes away from the lakefront estates.
"Interlaken is one of the northern shore's hidden gems — a tiny 0.36-square-mile borough of about 900 almost entirely surrounded by the two arms of Deal Lake. Its very name, 'between the lakes,' describes its setting: a quiet, leafy enclave of estate homes on winding streets, minutes from the beaches, at a median near $1.37M."
Interlaken cross-shops with Allenhurst, Loch Arbour, Deal, and Asbury Park.
Town | Median | Population | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
Interlaken ★ | $1,370,000 | ~900 | 0.36 mi² |
$1,600,000 | 472 | 0.25 mi² | |
$1,600,000 | 224 | 0.085 mi² | |
$2,830,000 | ~900 | 1.16 mi² | |
$700,000 | 15,188 | 1.40 mi² |
★ Subject borough. Sources: Monmouth County government; U.S. Census. Interlaken population approximately 900 (2020 census); 0.36 sq mi land on the northern Monmouth shore, an estate enclave almost entirely surrounded by the two arms of Deal Lake (its name means "between the lakes"), bordering Allenhurst and Asbury Park; students attend area schools through sending relationships; a borough government; median sale price approximately $1,370,000. Comparison figures approximate. Verify property-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
The Lake Defines It. Few boroughs are as shaped by water as Interlaken — the two arms of Deal Lake give it both beauty and a true sense of seclusion.
Estate Streets in Miniature. The borough packs gracious, estate-scale homes and winding avenues into a remarkably small footprint.
Quiet but Connected. Tucked away yet minutes from Asbury Park and the beaches, Interlaken offers privacy without sacrificing access.
Rarely Available. With so few homes, listings here are scarce — buying in Interlaken often means waiting for the right one.
Schools + Government. Interlaken students attend area schools through sending relationships, under a borough government.
Around $1.37M. Estate homes run $2M-$3.5M+, the core market $1.1M-$2M, and smaller homes $800K-$1.1M.
"Between the lakes" — a reference to the borough's setting between the two arms of Deal Lake that nearly surround it.
Its estate homes, winding tree-lined streets, Deal Lake frontage, and quiet, exclusive character minutes from the ocean.
As a small borough, Interlaken's students attend area schools through sending relationships.
NY + NJ licensed · cinematic 4K drone marketing · lakeside-estate & northern-shore specialists.
Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.