Homes for sale in Allenhurst, NJ — current 07711 listings, median sale prices, the substantial 0.32 mi² historic Jersey Shore Monmouth County borough between Asbury Park and Deal with substantial National Register of Historic Places designation, K-8 own + 9-12 Asbury Park HS sending (also alternative options), substantial Allenhurst Beach Club, substantial Edgemere + Ocean Avenue oceanfront corridor, and substantial preserved Victorian + Edwardian architectural character.
A tiny historic oceanfront borough with its own train. A 0.25-square-mile enclave of historic homes, beach-club oceanfront, and Deal Lake frontage — with its own NJ Transit station.
Allenhurst is one of the Jersey Shore's most charming small enclaves — a 0.25-square-mile oceanfront borough of 472 residents (2020) laid out as a planned community in 1895 and still defined by its historic district of grand homes. Tucked between Deal and Loch Arbour, with the Atlantic on one side and Deal Lake on the other, it pairs storied architecture with a rare convenience: its own train station.
The median sale runs near $1.6M, across historic homes in the borough's protected district, properties near the Allenhurst Beach Club, and homes along the Deal Lake frontage. The Allenhurst NJ Transit station sits on the North Jersey Coast Line, and the borough sends its students to neighboring schools through a sending relationship. Run under a borough government, Allenhurst offers historic character, oceanfront access, and a one-seat-ready location in a remarkably small footprint.
Allenhurst draws buyers who want historic architecture, oceanfront access, and the rare convenience of a train station — all in a tiny, tight-knit borough. Its protected historic district and dual waterfront make it one of the shore's most distinctive small markets.
Laid out in 1895, Allenhurst's grand historic homes and protected district give it architectural character unlike anywhere nearby.
The Atlantic and its beach club to the east, Deal Lake to the west — water frames the borough on two sides.
Few enclaves this small have their own NJ Transit station on the North Jersey Coast Line — a real commuter advantage.
A small, high-value market of historic homes near the ocean and the lake.
The grandest historic homes near the oceanfront and beach club, on the borough's most prized blocks.
Comparable to: Deal, Spring Lake.
Historic district homes and Deal Lake-frontage properties across the heart of the borough.
Comparable to: Loch Arbour, Interlaken.
Smaller homes and renovation opportunities — the most attainable way into this historic oceanfront enclave.
Comparable to: West Allenhurst, Ocean Township upper.
A tiny borough organized between the ocean and the lake:
The oceanfront blocks near the Allenhurst Beach Club — the borough's most coveted addresses on the Atlantic.
The heart of the 1895 planned community — grand historic homes on the borough's protected, tree-lined streets.
The blocks near the Allenhurst NJ Transit station — historic homes with a true commuter advantage at the door.
The western edge along Deal Lake — water-facing homes on New Jersey's largest coastal lake.
The neighborhoods just west of the borough core — more attainable homes in the broader Allenhurst area.
"Allenhurst is one of the shore's most charming small enclaves — a 0.25-square-mile oceanfront borough of 472 laid out as a planned community in 1895 and still defined by its historic district of grand homes. With the Atlantic on one side and Deal Lake on the other, and a rare convenience in its own train station, it pairs storied architecture with oceanfront access at a median near $1.6M."
Allenhurst cross-shops with Deal, Loch Arbour, Interlaken, and Asbury Park.
Town | Median | Population | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
Allenhurst ★ | $1,600,000 | 472 | 0.25 mi² |
$2,830,000 | ~900 | 1.16 mi² | |
$1,600,000 | 224 | 0.085 mi² | |
$1,370,000 | ~900 | 0.36 mi² | |
$700,000 | 15,188 | 1.40 mi² |
★ Subject borough. Sources: Monmouth County government; U.S. Census. Allenhurst population 472 (2020 census); 0.25 sq mi land on the northern Monmouth oceanfront; a planned community laid out in 1895, defined by its historic district of grand homes, with the Allenhurst Beach Club on the Atlantic and Deal Lake frontage to the west, and its own NJ Transit station on the North Jersey Coast Line; the borough sends its students to neighboring schools through a sending relationship; a borough government; median sale price approximately $1,600,000. Comparison figures approximate. Verify property-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
History You Can Live In. The 1895 plan and protected historic district mean Allenhurst's character is preserved street by street — a rarity on the modern shore.
Two Waterfronts. The ocean and beach club to the east, Deal Lake to the west — few enclaves this small are framed by water on both sides.
A Commuter's Secret. Its own train station gives Allenhurst a practical edge that most tiny shore boroughs simply don't have.
Small and Tight-Knit. With under 500 residents, Allenhurst is intimate and community-minded, with a strong sense of shared identity.
Schools + Government. The borough sends its students to neighboring schools through a sending relationship, under a borough government.
Around $1.6M. The grandest oceanfront-area homes run $2.5M-$5M+, the core market $1.3M-$2.5M, and smaller homes $900K-$1.3M.
Its 1895 planned-community origins and protected historic district, the Allenhurst Beach Club, and its setting between the ocean and Deal Lake.
Yes — the Allenhurst station sits on NJ Transit's North Jersey Coast Line, a rare convenience for such a small borough.
As a very small borough, Allenhurst sends its students to neighboring schools through a sending relationship.
NY + NJ licensed · cinematic 4K drone marketing · historic-district & oceanfront-enclave specialists.
Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.