Homes for sale in Allenhurst, NJ — current 07711 listings, median sale prices, the substantial 0.32 mi² historic Jersey Shore Monmouth County borough between Asbury Park and Deal with substantial National Register of Historic Places designation, K-8 own + 9-12 Asbury Park HS sending (also alternative options), substantial Allenhurst Beach Club, substantial Edgemere + Ocean Avenue oceanfront corridor, and substantial preserved Victorian + Edwardian architectural character.
If you're searching for homes for sale in Allenhurst, NJ, you're looking at one of the most distinctive — and smallest — Jersey Shore Monmouth County boroughs. Allenhurst is a tiny 0.28-square-mile borough of just 472 residents (2020, 553rd of 565 NJ municipalities by population), formally incorporated April 26, 1897 from portions of Ocean Township, and named after early settler Abner Allen (whose 120-acre farm — boarding house since at least 1846 — became the substantial Coast Land Improvement Company resort development in 1895). The substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District is listed on the National Register of Historic Places — featuring substantial Tudor Revival, Victorian, Queen Anne, and Shingle-style historic homes built in the substantial late-19th to early-20th-century planned-resort era. In 2006, Allenhurst ranked #131 in Forbes magazine's list of the most expensive ZIP codes in the country. The borough operates as a non-operating school district — sending K-8 students to West Long Branch School District and 9-12 students to Shore Regional High School on a per-pupil tuition basis (since July 2017). Allenhurst real estate trades at a median sale price exceeding $1,000,000 per city-data 2024 (up from $360,400 in 2000 — approximately 178% appreciation), with substantial Seashore Colonial and Victorian inventory anchoring the substantial primary-residence and substantial summer-residence community character.
Allenhurst is one of the rarest Jersey Shore Monmouth County boroughs — a tiny 0.28-square-mile borough (554th of 565 NJ municipalities by total area; 50th of 53 in Monmouth County) that combines substantial Atlantic Ocean beachfront, the substantial National Register-listed Allenhurst Residential Historic District (substantial Tudor Revival, Victorian, Queen Anne, and Shingle-style 1895-1910 inventory), the substantial Allenhurst NJ Transit station (North Jersey Coast Line, direct NY Penn service), substantial proximity to Asbury Park (immediately south) and Deal (immediately north) at the center of the substantial wealthy Jersey Shore string of communities, and the substantial Deal Lake frontage (largest artificial lake in Monmouth County, 0.63 sq km, drains directly to Atlantic Ocean). Allenhurst was formally incorporated as a borough by an act of the New Jersey Legislature on April 26, 1897, from portions of Ocean Township. The borough was named after Abner Allen — early settler whose 120-acre farm (operated as a boarding house for vacationers since at least 1846) was purchased on August 10, 1895 by the substantial Coast Land Improvement Company (under President Edwin P. Benjamin and Vice-President James M. Ralston, both of Asbury Park) for $120,000 to develop "an exclusive resort community to attract only the best class of refined summer residents." Within a year of the first residential lot purchases, 30 cottages were constructed alongside substantial sidewalks, sewers, electric lights, and an artesian well system. Substantial Walsh Act (Board of Commissioners) form of New Jersey government. Mayor: Frieda O. Adjmi (term ends May 2028); Municipal Clerk: Donna Campagna. The borough is at the center of the substantial wealthy communities between Asbury Park and Long Branch.
The substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District is listed on the National Register of Historic Places — featuring substantial Tudor Revival, Victorian, Queen Anne, and Shingle-style historic homes built in the substantial late-19th to early-20th-century planned-resort era (substantial 1895-1910 development period under the Coast Land Improvement Company). The Company hired George D. Morrow of Trenton as Superintendent of building operations; had its own architects, builders, and lumber yard; and financed a pavilion and bathhouses at the end of Allen Avenue. By 1896, the development was first referred to as Allenhurst (named after the Allen family), per a May 11, 1896 Asbury Park Daily Press article: "It Is Now Allenhurst."
Allenhurst is a non-operating school district — the borough does not operate any public schools of its own. Since July 20, 2017, Allenhurst students attend the West Long Branch School District (K-8, 135 Locust Avenue, West Long Branch, 574 students) and Shore Regional High School (132 Route 36, West Long Branch, grades 9-12, 573 students, DFG "FG") on a per-pupil tuition basis. Allenhurst Board of Education President Larry O'Rourke spearheaded the substantial 2017 transition. Allenhurst joined Interlaken and Loch Arbour — both also non-operating districts — in this sending arrangement (replacing the previous longstanding Asbury Park K-12 relationship). Approximately 38 Allenhurst school-age children at the time of the transition.
The substantial Allenhurst NJ Transit station (on the North Jersey Coast Line) provides direct one-seat service to NY Penn Station — making Allenhurst one of the most accessible Jersey Shore boroughs from New York City. East-west Corlies Avenue connects directly to the station and to the broader Monmouth Road / County Route 15 north-south corridor. Substantial GSP access via adjacent Asbury Park. Approximately 38.9 miles from Newark. The substantial Allenhurst Beach Club anchors the substantial private-beach culture characteristic of the central Jersey Shore.
Allenhurst's housing stock concentrates in substantial Seashore Colonial, Victorian, Queen Anne, Tudor Revival, and Shingle-style estate-scale single-family historic residences — substantial substantial late-19th to early-20th-century planned-resort inventory within the substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District. Median sale prices: City-data 2024 median house or condo value over $1,000,000 (up from $360,400 in 2000 — approximately 178% appreciation over 24 years); mean prices 2024 all housing units over $1,000,000; mean detached houses over $1,000,000. Forbes ranked Allenhurst's 07711 ZIP #131 in the most expensive ZIP codes in the country (2006). Cost of living index 127.1 (substantially above U.S. average of 100). Median household income $96,529 (2024, up from $85,000 in 2000); median per capita income $87,295 (2024, up from $42,710 in 2000 — approximately 104% appreciation). Median gross rent $1,627. 5.9% poverty rate. The substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District inventory commands substantial premium pricing — many residences trade well above $2 million for restored historic Tudor Revival, Queen Anne, and Shingle-style estate residences. Ocean-block residences command the substantial premium of any borough inventory.
Substantial smaller (by Allenhurst standards) Victorian, Queen Anne, and Shingle-style historic residences in the western Allenhurst section. Substantial original residences from the 1895-1910 planned-resort development period requiring some restoration or substantially-modernized homes on modest lots within the substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District. The most accessible Allenhurst entry point — substantial buyer competition reflects the substantial National Register district premium and the substantial NJCL train accessibility.
Four- and five-bedroom restored Tudor Revival, Victorian, and Shingle-style historic estate residences alongside substantial newer Seashore Colonial-style residences — many gut-renovated to studs while preserving substantial period architectural character (wraparound porches, ornate trim, multi-story Victorian detail, slate roofs, original woodwork). The largest segment by transaction volume — primary-residence year-round + substantial second-home demand anchored by the substantial Jersey Shore beachfront-borough character.
Substantial ocean-block estate residences with Atlantic Ocean views and substantial Allenhurst Beach Club proximity, the borough's most-significant substantial Tudor Revival and Queen Anne mansions, and substantial multi-story Seashore Colonial estates on substantial corner lots. Among the most-distinctive Jersey Shore historic mansion inventory anywhere — substantially comparable to upper-tier Deal inventory but with substantially more accessible NJCL train commute. Some ocean-block residences trade well above $6 million.
Allenhurst's compact 0.25-square-mile land footprint segments by proximity to the Atlantic Ocean beachfront, the substantial Allenhurst Beach Club, the Allenhurst NJ Transit station, Deal Lake (western border), and the substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District core. Despite its substantially small footprint, Allenhurst has substantial distinctive named pockets.
The substantial Atlantic Ocean-facing residential blocks — anchored by the substantial Allenhurst Beach Club. Substantial ocean-block estate residences with Atlantic Ocean views and substantial private-beach culture. Among the most-distinctive Jersey Shore historic mansion inventory anywhere — substantial multi-story Tudor Revival, Queen Anne, and Shingle-style historic estates command substantial premium pricing. The substantial 1895-1910 pavilion and bathhouses at the end of Allen Avenue (financed by the original Coast Land Improvement Company development) anchor the substantial historic beach character.
The substantial National Register-listed Allenhurst Residential Historic District — comprising substantial historic residences built in the substantial 1895-1910 planned-resort era. Substantial Tudor Revival, Victorian, Queen Anne, Colonial Revival, and Shingle-style residences with substantial period architectural detail. Many residences have been substantially restored or gut-renovated to studs while preserving substantial period character. Among the most-distinctive small-borough historic residential inventory anywhere on the Jersey Shore.
The substantial east-west Corlies Avenue commercial-residential spine — anchored by the Allenhurst NJ Transit station (on the North Jersey Coast Line, direct NY Penn service). Substantial single-family residential blocks within walking distance of the substantial train station, plus the substantial commercial inventory along Corlies Avenue. Substantial NYC weekday commuter and weekend weekend-resident demand drives substantial primary-residence value. Among the most-watched residential pockets for substantial NYC-commute buyers.
The substantial Deal Lake-facing residential blocks at Allenhurst's western border. Deal Lake — the largest artificial lake in Monmouth County (0.63 square kilometers / 158 acres) — borders Allenhurst to the west and is also bordered by Asbury Park, Deal, Neptune Township, Loch Arbour, Ocean Township, and Interlaken. The substantial Deal Lake drains directly into the Atlantic Ocean. Substantial Deal Lake-facing residences command substantial premium and substantial waterfront character.
West Allenhurst is an unincorporated area immediately west of Allenhurst Borough (technically within Ocean Township, sharing the 07711 ZIP with Allenhurst plus Loch Arbour). Substantial single-family residential inventory at substantially more accessible pricing than the Allenhurst Borough Historic District core. Bordered by Allenhurst Borough (E), Deal (NE), and Interlaken (S). Substantial walking-distance proximity to the Allenhurst NJ Transit station via Corlies Avenue.
"Allenhurst is the rare 0.28-square-mile Jersey Shore borough where Forbes ranked the 07711 ZIP #131 in the most expensive ZIP codes in the country (2006), and median home values exceed $1 million per city-data 2024. The substantial 1895-1910 planned-resort development by the Coast Land Improvement Company, the substantial National Register-listed Allenhurst Residential Historic District (Tudor Revival, Victorian, Queen Anne, Shingle-style inventory), the Allenhurst NJ Transit station, and the substantial private Allenhurst Beach Club anchor one of the most-distinctive small-borough historic residential markets anywhere on the central Jersey Shore."
Allenhurst cross-shops most directly with Deal (immediately north, similar upscale Jersey Shore borough, higher pricing), Asbury Park (immediately south, much larger neighbor, much lower pricing, substantial entertainment district), Spring Lake (south, similar substantial historic Jersey Shore character), and Interlaken (immediately southwest, smaller borough, sends to same West Long Branch + Shore Regional schools).
| Town | Median Sale | Avg. Tax | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allenhurst ★ | $1,600,000 | $22,800 | 0.25 mi² |
| Deal | $2,800,000 | $22,500 | 1.18 mi² |
| Asbury Park | $700,000 | $7,885 | 1.4 mi² |
| Spring Lake | $2,200,000 | $15,800 | 1.33 mi² |
| Interlaken | $950,000 | $13,400 | 0.34 mi² |
★ Subject town. Sources: Monmouth County Board of Taxation (2025 certified data); Allenhurst is a non-operating school district sending K-8 to West Long Branch (574 students) and 9-12 to Shore Regional High School (573 students, DFG "FG"); city-data 2024 median home value over $1,000,000 (up from $360,400 in 2000 — ~178% appreciation); Forbes 2006 ranked Allenhurst's 07711 ZIP #131 most expensive in the country; cost of living index 127.1. Allenhurst pricing varies substantially by section — Ocean Block residences command substantial premium over Historic District core and West Allenhurst section. Verify section-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
Borough History & the 1895 Planned-Resort Origin. The area south of Long Branch (today the municipalities of Allenhurst and Deal) was referred to by the mid-19th century as Deal Beach. One of the first settlers in the area was Abner Allen, who resided in what would become Allenhurst since at least 1846. Allen and his family owned a 120-acre farm approximately 0.3 miles from the ocean, and the family utilized their farmhouse as a boarding house for vacationers along the shore. Gilbert M. Spier (namesake of Spier Avenue) of New York City also owned a 20-acre lot in the area that would later become Allenhurst. On August 10, 1895, the Coast Land Improvement Company — under the direction of President Edwin P. Benjamin and Vice-President James M. Ralston, both of Asbury Park — purchased the 120-acre Allen farm to plan and build "an exclusive resort community to attract only the best class of refined summer residents." Benjamin immediately began making improvements to the property. Benjamin and Ralston hired George D. Morrow of Trenton as Superintendent of building operations. Within a year of the first residential lot purchases, 30 cottages were constructed alongside substantial sidewalks, sewers, electric lights, and an artesian well system. The Company had its own architects, builders, and lumber yard, and financed the construction of a substantial pavilion and bathhouses at the end of Allen Avenue. The Allenhurst Inn — formerly the Allen family boarding house — was given several modern improvements. By 1896, the development was first referred to as Allenhurst (named after the Allen family) per a May 11, 1896 Asbury Park Daily Press article ("It Is Now Allenhurst"). Allenhurst was formally incorporated as a borough by an act of the New Jersey Legislature on April 26, 1897, from portions of Ocean Township.
Allenhurst Residential Historic District & Architecture. The substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District is listed on the National Register of Historic Places — comprising substantial historic residences built in the substantial 1895-1910 planned-resort era. Substantial architectural styles in the district include Tudor Revival, Victorian, Queen Anne, Colonial Revival, and Shingle-style. The substantial period architectural detail (wraparound porches, multi-story Victorian gingerbread, slate roofs, original woodwork, ornate trim) anchors substantial buyer demand. Many residences have been substantially restored or gut-renovated to studs while preserving substantial period architectural character. Among the most-distinctive small-borough historic residential inventory anywhere on the Jersey Shore.
Non-Operating School District & the 2017 Transition. Allenhurst is a non-operating school district — the borough does not operate any public schools of its own. From the 2012-2013 through 2015-2016 school years, only one Allenhurst public school student attended the previous K-12 Asbury Park sending arrangement (during 2013-2014). On July 20, 2017, NJ Acting Commissioner of Education Kimberly Harrington approved Allenhurst's petition to sever the longstanding K-12 sending relationship with Asbury Park and establish substantial new per-pupil tuition relationships with the West Long Branch School District (K-8, 135 Locust Avenue, West Long Branch) and the Shore Regional High School District (132 Route 36, West Long Branch). Allenhurst joined neighboring Interlaken and Loch Arbour — also non-operating districts — in this sending arrangement. Approximately 38 Allenhurst school-age children at the time of the transition. Allenhurst Board of Education President Larry O'Rourke described the transition as a substantial multi-year solution providing parents and new residents substantial public-school options.
Demographics, Economics & Deal Lake. The 2020 population of 472 residents (553rd of 565 NJ municipalities by population; 52nd of 53 in Monmouth County) represents the borough's substantially small character. The 2024 estimate of 466 residents reflects population stability. Median household income $96,529 (2024, up from $85,000 in 2000); median per capita income $87,295 (2024, up from $42,710 in 2000). Median house or condo value 2024 over $1,000,000 (up from $360,400 in 2000 — approximately 178% appreciation over 24 years). Cost of living index 127.1. Median age 50.7. Forbes ranked Allenhurst's 07711 ZIP #131 in the most expensive ZIP codes in the country (2006). The substantial Deal Lake — the largest artificial lake in Monmouth County (0.63 square kilometers / 158 acres) — borders Allenhurst to the west. Deal Lake is also bordered by Asbury Park, Deal, Neptune Township, Loch Arbour, Ocean Township, and Interlaken. Deal Lake drains directly into the Atlantic Ocean.
The median sale price in Allenhurst tracks at over $1,000,000 per city-data 2024 (median house or condo value over $1,000,000, up from $360,400 in 2000 — approximately 178% appreciation over 24 years). Mean prices 2024: all housing units over $1,000,000; detached houses over $1,000,000. Forbes ranked Allenhurst's 07711 ZIP #131 in the most expensive ZIP codes in the country (2006). Substantial historic Tudor Revival, Victorian, Queen Anne, and Shingle-style estate residences in the substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District command substantial premium pricing. Prices range from approximately $950,000 for entry-tier smaller historic residences to over $6 million for the borough's most-significant ocean-block estate residences with Atlantic Ocean views.
Allenhurst is a non-operating school district — the borough does not operate any public schools of its own. Since July 20, 2017, Allenhurst students attend the West Long Branch School District (K-8, 135 Locust Avenue, West Long Branch, 574 students, 30% minority enrollment) and Shore Regional High School (132 Route 36, West Long Branch, grades 9-12, 573 students, DFG "FG") on a per-pupil tuition basis. The substantial Shore Regional High School District also serves Interlaken, Loch Arbour, Monmouth Beach, Oceanport, Sea Bright, and West Long Branch — seven Monmouth County communities total. Allenhurst replaced the previous longstanding K-12 Asbury Park sending arrangement via the 2017 transition.
The substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District is listed on the National Register of Historic Places — featuring substantial Tudor Revival, Victorian, Queen Anne, Colonial Revival, and Shingle-style historic homes built in the substantial 1895-1910 planned-resort era. The district reflects the substantial Coast Land Improvement Company's exclusive resort community development under President Edwin P. Benjamin and Vice-President James M. Ralston, both of Asbury Park, beginning August 10, 1895 with the purchase of Abner Allen's 120-acre farm. By 1896 the substantial 30-cottage development was first referred to as Allenhurst (named after the Allen family) per a May 11, 1896 Asbury Park Daily Press article ("It Is Now Allenhurst"). Allenhurst was formally incorporated as a borough on April 26, 1897.
Yes — the substantial Allenhurst NJ Transit station (on the North Jersey Coast Line) provides direct one-seat service to NY Penn Station, making Allenhurst one of the most accessible Jersey Shore boroughs from New York City. East-west Corlies Avenue connects directly to the substantial station and to the broader Monmouth Road / County Route 15 north-south corridor. Substantial GSP access via adjacent Asbury Park. Approximately 38.9 miles from Newark.
The Prodigy Team works the Ocean Block / Atlantic beachfront, the substantial Allenhurst Residential Historic District core, the Corlies Avenue NJ Transit station corridor, the Deal Lake-frontage western Allenhurst pocket, and the West Allenhurst unincorporated section every week. Cinematic 4K aerial drone marketing — particularly valuable for Allenhurst's substantial Tudor Revival, Victorian, and Queen Anne estate historic residences plus the borough's substantial Atlantic Ocean and Deal Lake-frontage context — NYS/NJ broker representation, and 20+ years of Monmouth County transactional experience.
Contact The Prodigy TeamProdigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.