Homes for sale in Keyport Borough, NJ — a 1.4-square-mile Raritan Bay waterfront Monmouth County borough nicknamed the "Pearl of the Bayshore." Median sale ~$485K. Incorporated as a borough on April 14, 1908, from portions of Raritan Township (now Hazlet). Population 7,365 (2020). Defined by its walkable historic downtown Main Street commercial district, Keyport Harbor and waterfront on Raritan Bay, and rich maritime heritage including shipbuilding and oystering. Students attend Keyport Public Schools and Keyport HS Red Raiders. Mayor Collette Kennedy. Major roads: Route 36 + Broad Street. ZIP 07735.
If you're searching for homes for sale in Keyport, NJ, you're looking at the historic Raritan Bay waterfront borough — a small 1.46-square-mile borough of 7,204 residents (2020) at the northwest corner of Monmouth County, prominently displaying the nickname "Pearl of the Bayshore" (formal seal) and "Gateway to the Bayshore" (longtime water tower designation). Keyport operates a K-12 own school district (Keyport Public Schools, 1,004 students across 2 schools, DFG "CD") and feeds into Keyport High School (the Red Raiders — established 1927, also serves substantial Union Beach students via sending/receiving relationship). The borough was formally incorporated on April 2, 1908. Keyport real estate trades at a median sale price near $390,000-$464,000 — substantially more accessible than the surrounding Bayshore municipalities — with substantial Colonial residential inventory plus large apartment and condominium buildings offering commanding views of the Raritan Bay and the New York City skyline. The borough sits at the junction of Routes 35 and 36 with direct GSP access, and the historic Front Street and Broad Street commercial corridor anchors the borough's distinctive waterfront character.
Keyport is the rare small Bayshore Monmouth County borough that combines substantial Raritan Bay waterfront with NYC skyline views, a K-12 own school district (Keyport Public Schools, 1,004 students across 2 schools — substantial enrollment for a 1.38-square-mile borough), the historic Keyport High School (the Red Raiders — established 1927, also serves Union Beach students via sending/receiving), the substantial Routes 35 and 36 junction (direct GSP access), and substantial accessible pricing relative to the surrounding K-12 own-district Bayshore municipalities. Keyport prides itself as the "Pearl of the Bayshore" (formal seal) and "Gateway to the Bayshore" (longtime water tower nickname). The borough was formally incorporated on April 2, 1908. Keyport Harbor (an arm of the Raritan Bay, formerly known as Brown's Point Cove) is fed by Matawan Creek, Luppatatong Creek, and Chingarora Creek. The borough is part of the substantial Raritan Bayshore region — from The Amboys (Perth Amboy and South Amboy in Middlesex County) to Sandy Hook (in Monmouth County), encompassing 12+ shoreline communities. Approximately 25 miles from Manhattan. Mayor: Rose P. Araneo (R, term ends December 31, 2026); Administrator Kimberly Humphrey; Municipal Clerk Michele Clark. Borough Council form of NJ government. Population 7,204 (2020, est. 7,099 in 2023) — a slight decrease from earlier counts but substantially stable.
Keyport Public Schools operates a comprehensive K-12 own community public school district with 2 schools — 1,004 students (2023-24), 10.0:1 ratio, 100.0 FTE faculty, classified by NJ DOE as DFG "CD." Superintendent: Lisa M. Savoia. District offices: 370 Broad Street, Keyport (732-212-6100). The 2 schools include Keyport Central Elementary School (PreK-8) and Keyport High School (grades 9-12). For a 1.38-square-mile borough, the K-12 own district structure provides substantial walkability — nearly all borough children can walk to school. The district provides instruction for all borough K-12 students plus receives Union Beach students for grades 9-12 via sending/receiving relationship.
Keyport High School (351 Broad Street) was established in 1927. KHS enrolled 372 students (2024-25), 11.1:1 ratio, 33.5 FTE faculty. Athletic teams: Red Raiders (Red and White). Shore Conference. Principal Michael P. Waters Sr. Literary publication Portals. Keyport HS receives most Union Beach students via sending/receiving relationship (Union Beach's K-8 Memorial School feeds into KHS for grades 9-12 — substantial Union Beach demographic anchors KHS enrollment alongside Keyport's resident students). A handful of Union Beach students are also accepted into Red Bank Regional HS via competitive admissions to its three specialized programs (visual and performing arts; information technology; finance). The borough's distinctive small-town K-12 character drives substantial community-school continuity.
Keyport sits at the junction of Routes 35 and 36 with direct Garden State Parkway access — substantial regional commuter accessibility. The borough is approximately 25 miles from Manhattan. The substantial Raritan Bay waterfront (Keyport Harbor, fed by Matawan Creek, Luppatatong Creek, and Chingarora Creek) offers substantial NYC skyline views from multiple borough vantage points — particularly the waterfront park and the West Front Street commercial corridor. The nearest NJ Transit train station is at Aberdeen Township (Aberdeen-Matawan station on the North Jersey Coast Line). NJ Transit bus service operates through the borough.
Keyport's housing stock concentrates in two primary categories — substantial Colonial residential single-family inventory across the borough's substantial residential interior, and large apartment and condominium buildings (the condos are relatively new, built 10-15 years ago per local Realtors) offering commanding views of the Raritan Bay and the NYC skyline. Median sale prices: Homes.com reports median home price $390,000 (well below the state median of $500,000, making Keyport a relatively affordable town within the New York metropolitan area). City-data 2024 median house or condo value $463,896 (up from $140,800 in 2000 — approximately 229% appreciation over 24 years). Mean prices 2024: all housing units $372,580; detached houses $372,236; townhouses or other attached units $430,821; in 2-unit structures $719,234; in 5+-unit structures $318,752. Median household income $79,963 (2024, up from $43,869 in 2000); median per capita income $48,700 (2024). Median gross rent $1,481. Cost of living index 119.0. The borough's substantially accessible pricing relative to surrounding Bayshore K-12 own-district municipalities (Hazlet, Aberdeen, Matawan) drives substantial demand from first-time buyers and primary-residence relocators.
One- and two-bedroom condo units in Keyport's substantial post-2010 condo and townhouse inventory (5+-unit structures mean $318,752 per city-data 2024), townhomes (mean $430,821), and smaller Colonial-style single-family residences on small lots. Recent active listings include Cliffwood-area condos in the $250K-$350K range. The most accessible Keyport entry point — first-time buyers, NYC commuters, and primary-residence relocators compete on substantially well-priced inventory. Median condo listing tracks at approximately $300K-$400K.
Three- and four-bedroom Colonial-style single-family residences throughout the borough's substantial residential interior (mean detached house price $372,236 per city-data 2024). Substantial post-war and pre-2000 single-family inventory across multiple residential blocks. The largest segment by transaction volume — primary-residence year-round families anchored by Keyport Public Schools K-12 plus the substantial walkable downtown Front Street + Broad Street commercial spine. The Homes.com median home price $390,000 anchors this tier.
Larger Colonial and Victorian-era single-family residences with substantial Raritan Bay views, the borough's most-significant waterfront-adjacent inventory, and post-2010 newer-construction condos with commanding NYC skyline views (some duplex / 2-unit structures mean $719,234 per city-data 2024). Among the most accessible Bayshore waterfront pricing available — substantially below comparable bay-view inventory in Atlantic Highlands or Highlands.
Keyport's compact 1.38-square-mile borough segments by proximity to the historic Front Street and Broad Street commercial spine, the Raritan Bay waterfront, the K-12 schools complex, and the substantial residential interior.
The substantial waterfront commercial spine along West Front Street — anchored by Keyport's primary downtown commercial inventory, the historic Keyport Fishery (a long-standing fixture preparing fresh seafood from Raritan Bay, cash-only, located along West Front Street), substantial restaurant inventory, the Keyport Steamboat Dock historic landmark, and the Raritan Bay waterfront park with commanding NYC skyline views. Substantial mixed-use commercial and residential character along the historic downtown corridor.
The substantial Broad Street commercial-residential spine — anchored by Keyport Central Elementary School (335 Broad Street), Keyport High School (351 Broad Street), and Keyport Public Schools administrative offices (370 Broad Street). Substantial Colonial-style single-family residential inventory across multiple residential blocks, with substantial walking-distance proximity to the borough's K-12 educational complex. Among the most-watched primary-residence pockets, with substantial school-zone demand.
The substantial Raritan Bay-adjacent residential blocks with substantial NYC skyline views. Keyport Harbor (formerly Brown's Point Cove) is the substantial arm of the Raritan Bay anchoring the borough's waterfront. Substantial mid-century single-family residential inventory plus post-2010 newer-construction condos commanding substantial premium for bay views. Among the most-distinctive small-borough waterfront residential inventory anywhere on the Bayshore at substantially accessible pricing.
The substantial eastern Keyport residential blocks along Maple Place and adjacent corridors. Substantial Colonial-style single-family residential inventory, with substantial walking-distance proximity to both the Broad Street K-12 schools spine and the West Front Street downtown commercial corridor. Among the more accessible primary-residence Keyport pockets.
The southern Keyport section at the Routes 35 and 36 junction — substantial commercial corridor with direct GSP access. The substantial commercial frontage anchors the borough's regional gateway character ("Gateway to the Bayshore"). Substantial residential blocks adjacent to the commercial corridor offer some of the borough's more accessible entry-tier inventory, with substantial walking-distance and short-drive proximity to the rest of the borough.
"Keyport is the 'Pearl of the Bayshore' — a 1.38-square-mile waterfront borough with Raritan Bay frontage, commanding NYC skyline views, a substantial walkable K-12 own school district (Keyport Public Schools, 1,004 students), and substantial Colonial residential inventory at median $390K. The Red Raiders at Keyport HS (est 1927) plus the Routes 35/36 GSP junction anchor substantial primary-residence demand at substantially more accessible pricing than the surrounding K-12 own-district Bayshore municipalities."
Keyport cross-shops most directly with Aberdeen Township (immediately west, K-12 MARSD shared with Matawan, similar accessible pricing, NJ Transit access), Hazlet Township (immediately south/east, K-12 own district, NJ Transit access, similar pricing), Union Beach (immediately east, smaller Bayshore borough, K-8 plus sends 9-12 to Keyport HS, lower pricing, Sandy-impacted), and Old Bridge Township (immediately west in Middlesex County, much larger neighbor).
| Town | Median Sale | Avg. Tax | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keyport ★ | $464,000 | $8,200 | 1.38 mi² |
| Aberdeen Township | $694,000 | $9,200 | 5.44 mi² |
| Hazlet Township | $485,000 | $9,400 | 5.5 mi² |
| Union Beach | $425,000 | $7,800 | 1.93 mi² |
| Matawan | $565,000 | $10,200 | 2.36 mi² |
★ Subject town. Sources: Monmouth County Board of Taxation (2025 certified data), Keyport Public Schools NCES data (1,004 students K-12, 2 schools, DFG "CD"), Keyport HS 2024-25 enrollment 372 students; Homes.com median home price $390,000; city-data 2024 median house/condo value $463,896 (up from $140,800 in 2000); mean detached house $372,236; median household income $79,963 (2024, up from $43,869 in 2000). Keyport pricing varies substantially by section — verify section-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
Borough History & "Pearl of the Bayshore". Keyport was formally incorporated as a borough on April 2, 1908. The borough is a waterfront community located on the Raritan Bay in the substantial Raritan Valley region, and is a commuter town of New York City in the New York metropolitan area. Keyport prominently displays the formal nickname "Pearl of the Bayshore" (formal seal) and the longtime water tower nickname "Gateway to the Bayshore" — phrases reflecting the borough's substantial historical maritime, commercial, and residential character. The borough is governed under New Jersey's Borough form of government — Mayor and Borough Council. Mayor: Rose P. Araneo (R, term ends December 31, 2026); Administrator Kimberly Humphrey; Municipal Clerk Michele Clark. The 2020 population of 7,204 represents a slight decrease from the 2010 count of 7,240 (−0.5%) and from the 2000 count of 7,568 — population substantially stable over decades.
Keyport Harbor & the Maritime Heritage. Keyport Harbor (formerly known as Brown's Point Cove) is an arm of the Raritan Bay on the south side of the bay — fed by Matawan Creek, Luppatatong Creek, and Chingarora Creek. Maximum depth 8 feet (2.4 m). Managing agency NY/NJ Baykeeper. Substantial maritime heritage anchors the borough's distinctive character — Keyport was historically a substantial steamboat dock, fishing community, and Raritan Bay port. The substantial waterfront park at West Front Street offers commanding views of the NYC skyline, the Raritan Bay, and the broader Raritan Bayshore region. The Raritan Bayshore region encompasses 12+ shoreline communities from The Amboys (in Middlesex County) to Sandy Hook (in Monmouth County) — including Matawan, Aberdeen, Keyport, Union Beach, Hazlet, Keansburg, Middletown, Atlantic Highlands, and Highlands.
The Keyport Fishery. The Keyport Fishery is one of the borough's substantial historical commercial anchors — a long-standing fixture of the community preparing fresh seafood from the Raritan Bay for customers. The cash-only establishment sits along West Front Street in the downtown area. Local Realtor Harry Arnold opines: "If you're within 100 miles, come here and get some seafood. They prepare fish, shrimp, and scallops simply by running it and frying it." The fishery offers fish, crab cakes, clam chowder, shrimp, scallops, and substantial Raritan Bay seafood — a substantial small-town commercial anchor.
Demographics & Economics. Median household income $79,963 (2024, up from $43,869 in 2000 — approximately 82% appreciation); median per capita income $48,700 (2024, up from $23,288 in 2000). Median house or condo value $463,896 (2024) up from $140,800 (2000) — approximately 229% appreciation over 24 years. 9.1% poverty rate; substantial diversity in housing stock (43% single-family detached + townhomes + apartments mix). Median age data and demographic mix reflect substantial primary-residence year-round community character. Cost of living index 119.0 — substantially higher than U.S. average of 100. The substantial accessibility and Raritan Bay frontage drive substantial demand from primary-residence relocators throughout the broader NYC metropolitan area.
The median sale price in Keyport tracks at approximately $464,000 per city-data 2024 (median house or condo value $463,896, up from $140,800 in 2000 — approximately 229% appreciation over 24 years); Homes.com reports median home price $390,000 (well below the state median of $500,000). Mean prices 2024: all housing units $372,580; detached houses $372,236; townhouses $430,821; 2-unit structures $719,234; 5+-unit structures $318,752. Prices range from approximately $250,000 for entry-tier condo and townhouse units to over $1 million for the borough's most-significant substantially-restored Victorian-era estate residences and bay-view newer-construction inventory.
Keyport Public Schools operates a K-12 own community public school district with 2 schools and 1,004 students (2023-24), 10.0:1 ratio, DFG "CD." Superintendent: Lisa M. Savoia. District offices: 370 Broad Street. The 2 schools include Keyport Central Elementary School (PreK-8, 335 Broad Street) and Keyport High School (grades 9-12, 351 Broad Street, the Red Raiders, established 1927, 372 students 2024-25). The 1.38-square-mile borough footprint allows nearly all children to walk to school. Union Beach K-8 students attend Memorial School, then continue to Keyport HS for grades 9-12 via sending/receiving relationship. A handful of Union Beach students are accepted into Red Bank Regional HS via competitive admissions.
"Pearl of the Bayshore" is Keyport's official municipal nickname (formal seal), reflecting the borough's substantial Raritan Bay waterfront and distinctive historical maritime, commercial, and residential character. "Gateway to the Bayshore" is the borough's longtime water tower nickname — once proudly emblazoned on the town's prominent water tower. The borough sits at the junction of Routes 35 and 36 with direct GSP access, providing substantial regional gateway character to both the broader Bayshore region (12+ Raritan Bay coastline communities from The Amboys to Sandy Hook) and the broader Monmouth County interior.
No — Keyport does not have its own NJ Transit train station. The nearest NJ Transit train station is at Aberdeen Township (Aberdeen-Matawan station on the North Jersey Coast Line, approximately 2-3 miles from Keyport) providing direct one-seat service to NY Penn Station. The borough sits at the junction of Routes 35 and 36 with direct Garden State Parkway access — substantial regional commuter accessibility by car. NJ Transit bus service operates through the borough. Approximately 25 miles from Manhattan.
The Prodigy Team works the West Front Street waterfront commercial corridor, the Broad Street K-12 schools spine, the Keyport Harbor / bay-view residential pocket, the Maple Place eastern residential blocks, and the Routes 35/36 gateway commercial corridor every week. Cinematic 4K aerial drone marketing — particularly valuable for Keyport's substantial Raritan Bay waterfront inventory plus the borough's distinctive Colonial residential character — NYS/NJ broker representation, and 20+ years of Monmouth County transactional experience.
Contact The Prodigy TeamProdigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.
