Homes for sale in Highlands, NJ — current 07732 listings, median sale prices near $625K, the SeaStreak ferry terminal to Manhattan (40 min), the 1862 Twin Lights of Navesink, the new Henry Hudson Regional School District (formed July 2024 with Atlantic Highlands), Hartshorne Woods Park, and substantial post-Sandy elevated construction.
A historic bayfront borough with the Twin Lights and a ferry. The most accessible piece of the Bayshore waterfront, with Sandy Hook just across the inlet.
Highlands is a small, historic waterfront borough on the Bayshore — a 0.74-square-mile community of 4,621 residents (2020) tucked between the Navesink River, Sandy Hook Bay, and the hills crowned by the landmark Twin Lights. Compact and water-defined, it offers one of the most accessible footholds on the Monmouth waterfront, with a working harbor, a ferry to New York, and the beaches of Sandy Hook just across the inlet.
The median sale runs near $625K, among the more attainable on the Two River/Bayshore waterfront, across cottages, raised shore homes, and condos. The SeaStreak ferry connects the borough to Manhattan, the historic Twin Lights and Hartshorne Park anchor its setting, and students attend the Henry Hudson Regional schools. Incorporated in 1900 and run under a borough government, Highlands pairs genuine waterfront character with relative value.
Highlands appeals to buyers who want genuine Bayshore waterfront living, a ferry to New York, and a more attainable price than its glossier neighbors. Its history, harbor, and proximity to Sandy Hook make it a true coastal town.
The SeaStreak ferry connects Highlands directly to Manhattan, giving this small waterfront town a fast, scenic commute.
The beaches and trails of Sandy Hook sit just across the inlet, giving residents some of the best oceanfront access on the coast.
Highlands offers a more attainable entry to the Monmouth waterfront than Sea Bright or Rumson, with real coastal character.
A coastal market of cottages, raised shore homes, and condos.
View homes on the Twin Lights bluff and newer raised waterfront properties with bay and river outlooks.
Comparable to: Atlantic Highlands, Monmouth Beach.
Updated cottages, raised homes, and townhomes across the borough — the heart of the Highlands market.
Comparable to: Atlantic Highlands, Keansburg area.
Cottages, condos, and smaller homes near the downtown and harbor — the entry point to waterfront living.
Comparable to: Keansburg, Union Beach area.
A compact borough organized around the water and the bluff:
The walkable waterfront core along Bay Avenue and Shore Drive — restaurants, the harbor, and the most central homes.
The hilltop streets near the historic Twin Lights — elevated homes with sweeping river, bay, and ocean views.
A historic, secluded hillside enclave above the borough — wooded, private homes with elevation and views.
The neighborhoods facing the inlet and Sandy Hook — water-side homes with direct access to bay and ocean beaches.
The greener edges near Hartshorne Woods Park and the Henry Hudson Trail — the borough's recreational gateway.
"Highlands is a small, historic waterfront borough — a 0.74-square-mile community of 4,621 tucked between the Navesink River, Sandy Hook Bay, and the hills crowned by the Twin Lights. Compact and water-defined, it offers one of the most accessible footholds on the Monmouth waterfront, with a harbor, a ferry to New York, and Sandy Hook just across the inlet. With a median near $625K, it pairs genuine coastal character with relative value."
Highlands cross-shops with Atlantic Highlands, Sea Bright, Monmouth Beach, and Middletown.
Town | Median | Population | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
Highlands ★ | $625,000 | 4,621 | 0.74 mi² |
$925,000 | 4,414 | 4.56 mi² | |
$1,400,000 | 1,449 | 0.72 mi² | |
$1,290,000 | 3,174 | 1.04 mi² | |
$790,000 | 67,106 | 40.91 mi² |
★ Subject borough. Sources: Monmouth County government; U.S. Census. Highlands population 4,621 (2020 census); 0.74 sq mi land on the Bayshore, between the Navesink River and Sandy Hook Bay; home to the historic Twin Lights, a working harbor, and the SeaStreak ferry to New York, with Sandy Hook just across the inlet; incorporated in 1900; a borough government, part of the Henry Hudson Regional district; median sale price approximately $625,000. Comparison figures approximate. Verify property-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
A Ferry to the City. The SeaStreak connects Highlands directly to Manhattan, making this small waterfront town a real option for New York commuters who want coastal life.
Sandy Hook at the Door. Few towns put a national seashore this close — Sandy Hook's beaches and trails are a short hop across the inlet.
Value on the Water. Highlands offers genuine waterfront character at prices below Sea Bright, Rumson, and the oceanfront boroughs — a rare combination on this coast.
A Twin Lights Setting. The historic lighthouse and the bluff above town give Highlands a dramatic, storied backdrop you won't find elsewhere on the Bayshore.
Schools + Government. Highlands is served by a local elementary school and the Henry Hudson Regional School District (shared with Atlantic Highlands) under a borough government.
Around $625K. View and newer waterfront homes run $800K-$1.2M+, the core market $575K-$800K, and cottages and condos $400K-$575K.
Yes — the SeaStreak ferry serves the Highlands waterfront with fast service to Manhattan, a signature commute for the area.
The historic Twin Lights lighthouse, its working harbor, the SeaStreak ferry, and its location across the inlet from Sandy Hook's beaches.
A local elementary school plus the Henry Hudson Regional School District, shared with neighboring Atlantic Highlands, serve the borough.
NY + NJ licensed · cinematic 4K drone marketing · Bayshore waterfront & ferry-town specialists.
Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.