Homes for sale in Bay Head, NJ — current 08742 listings, median home price $2,243,000 (oceanfront trophy estates $5M-$17M+), the substantial 0.79 mi² Jersey Shore "Gold Coast" barrier island borough with substantial Bay Head Historic District (440 acres, 549 contributing buildings, architect Wilson Eyre Jr., NRHP Feb 1 2006), substantial NO BOARDWALK + direct beach access from beachfront residences, substantial 1882 stone seawall, K-8 own Bay Head Elementary + 9-12 Point Pleasant Beach HS Garnet Gulls sending (#1 Public HS in Ocean County), and substantial NJ Transit Bay Head Station southern terminus of North Jersey Coast Line.
If you're searching for homes for sale in Bay Head, NJ, you're looking at the substantial substantial upscale Jersey Shore barrier island borough at the substantial northern end of the Barnegat Peninsula in Ocean County — a 0.79-square-mile borough of just 930 residents (2020) renowned as part of the substantial Jersey Shore "Gold Coast". Bay Head was established and incorporated in 1886 — named for its location at the substantial "head" of Barnegat Bay, reflecting substantial maritime heritage. The substantial borough is anchored by the substantial Bay Head Historic District — a substantial 440-acre district with 549 contributing buildings, listed on the National Register of Historic Places (added February 1, 2006) and the New Jersey Register of Historic Places (designated November 18, 2005). The substantial historic district was designed primarily by substantial Philadelphia architect Wilson Eyre Jr. starting 1877 in substantial Shingle Style, Stick Style, Queen Anne, and Colonial Revival architectural styles. The substantial stone seawall built in 1882 has played a substantial substantial role in protecting the town. Bay Head is part of the substantial Bay Head School District (K-8 own, Bay Head Elementary School, 129 students, DFG FG); 9-12 students attend Point Pleasant Beach High School as part of a substantial sending/receiving relationship with the Point Pleasant Beach School District (Garnet Gulls, US News + Niche-ranked #1 Public HS in Ocean County). Bay Head real estate trades at substantial premium pricing — Homes.com median home price $2,243,000; Movoto recent median list $2,599,000 ($1,149/sqft); Redfin August 2025 median sale $4.5M; substantial listings range $1.55M-$17M; substantial August 2023 beachfront 5BR/6BA listed ~$8M. Borders Point Pleasant Beach N, Point Pleasant Borough W, and Mantoloking S. ZIP 08742.
Bay Head is the substantial substantial upscale Jersey Shore barrier island borough renowned as part of the substantial Jersey Shore "Gold Coast" — the substantial substantial substantial substantial premium-tier residential market segment between Point Pleasant Beach and Mantoloking. The substantial borough was named for its location at the "head" of Barnegat Bay, established and incorporated in 1886. The substantial 0.79-square-mile borough combines substantial preserved Shingle Style + Stick Style + Queen Anne + Colonial Revival historic district character (substantial 549 contributing structures across 440 acres), substantial substantial direct Atlantic Ocean beach frontage (unlike most NJ shore towns, Bay Head has NO boardwalk and NO restrictions between beachfront houses and the ocean — substantial unbeatable substantial direct beach access from beachfront residences), substantial K-8 own Bay Head Elementary + substantial 9-12 sending to Point Pleasant Beach HS (substantial #1 Public HS in Ocean County per US News + Niche), substantial substantial primary architect Wilson Eyre Jr. (Philadelphia, designed many of the substantial historic buildings starting 1877), substantial L. Ron Hubbard Residence at Bay Head (Shingle Style, individually listed on NRHP 2018), substantial 1882 stone seawall (one of the substantial earliest seawalls in NJ), and substantial substantial NJ Transit Bay Head Station (substantial substantial terminal of the North Jersey Coast Line, substantial direct ~2.5-hour NYC Penn Station service). Population 930 (2020), est. 965 (current), projected 977 (2025), substantial 0.6% annual rate of change. Substantial population swells substantially in summer months while maintaining substantial year-round residents. Density approximately 1,177/sq mi. Substantial 89.2% Caucasian, 0.6% African American, 0.6% Asian, 2.8% Two or More racial mix. Median household income $145,417 (2023 ACS). Substantial 1.8% poverty rate. Median age 57.9 years — substantial substantial retirement / second-home / primary-residence mix. Per Coldwell Banker realtor commentary: "Bay Head, an affluent beach town, is considered part of the Jersey Shore's Gold Coast" — substantial residents wake up to the substantial crashing sound of ocean waves steps from their front door.
The substantial Bay Head Historic District is a substantial 440-acre (180 ha) historic district — substantial 549 contributing buildings, 2 contributing sites, and 1 contributing structure. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (added February 1, 2006, NRHP Reference No. 05001566) and the New Jersey Register of Historic Places (designated November 18, 2005, NJRHP No. 3402). The substantial historic district was built starting 1877 with substantial primary architect Wilson Eyre Jr. (substantial Philadelphia architect). Substantial architectural styles include Shingle Style, Stick Style, Queen Anne, and Colonial Revival. The substantial district is significant for substantial architecture and transportation 1877-1940. Substantial part of the district extends into Point Pleasant. Substantial L. Ron Hubbard Residence at Bay Head (Shingle Style) was individually listed on NRHP 2018.
Bay Head operates the substantial Bay Head School District (K-8 own, Bay Head Elementary School, 129 students, DFG FG). Substantial 9-12 students attend Point Pleasant Beach High School at 700 Trenton Avenue, Point Pleasant Beach 08742 as part of a substantial sending/receiving relationship with the Point Pleasant Beach School District. Point Pleasant Beach HS — 326 students 2023-24, 38.3 FTE faculty, 8.5:1 ratio, Principal Nathan Grosshandler, Red/White, motto "The Few, The Proud, The Beach," Shore Conference, Garnet Gulls — substantial recently ranked #1 Public High School in Ocean County by US News and Niche.com. Substantial 22 AP courses with open enrollment. Substantial Apple Distinguished School District + Future Ready Schools NJ + Sustainable Jersey for Schools recognition.
Bay Head's substantial distinguishing characteristic from most Jersey Shore beach towns: NO boardwalk and NO restrictions between beachfront houses and the ocean. Substantial substantial substantial unbeatable substantial direct beach access from beachfront residences — substantial "the sand awaits you at the front door" (per Homes.com). With substantial unbeatable beach access comes substantial high housing prices. The substantial historic stone seawall built in 1882 — substantial one of the earliest seawalls in NJ — has played a substantial substantial role in protecting the town from substantial coastal storms. Substantial residential and substantial summer-rental Atlantic Ocean beachfront character.
Bay Head's substantial 0.79-square-mile housing stock concentrates in substantial preserved Wilson Eyre Jr.-era Shingle Style + Stick Style + Queen Anne + Colonial Revival historic residences (substantial late 19th + early 20th century vintage), substantial newer custom-build oceanfront residences (substantial seamlessly integrated to align with the borough's historical character), and substantial substantial bayside residences along Barnegat Bay. Median sale prices: Homes.com median home price $2,243,000 (substantial 12-month median sale $1,997,500 -4% YoY, average sale price last 12 months $2,525,079, average 44-day DOM); Movoto recent median list $2,599,000 ($1,149/sqft, 42-day DOM, 15 active listings, May 2026 median list $5.85M with 11 homes for sale ranging $1.55M-$17M); Zillow typical home value $1,817,529 (-6.5% YoY); Redfin August 2025 median sale $4.5M (+289.6% YoY — substantial reflects substantial single-month transaction skew with limited inventory); Coldwell Banker Riviera Realty: "Most homes are around or well over $1M in asking price." Per Homes.com, substantial August 2023 beachfront property 5BR/6BA listed for nearly $8M. Substantial median construction year 1966; substantial 11.4% of homes built before 1940s, 5.3% by 1949 (substantial historic district character); 6.1% built 2000-2009, 6.7% built 2010-2019, 0.3% newest wave. Substantial 79.4% owner-occupied; 20.6% tenant-occupied; 16.7% vacant (substantial substantial second-home / summer-residence character). Substantial median household income $145,417 (2023). The substantial substantial substantial typical-buyer demographic substantial requires substantial $469K+ annual income to afford median home (28% rule).
Substantial inland Shingle Style + Stick Style + Queen Anne preserved historic cottages within the substantial Bay Head Historic District. The most accessible Bay Head entry point — substantial primary-residence buyers and substantial second-home buyers seeking substantial substantial preserved Wilson Eyre Jr.-era historic character. Movoto May 2026 listings starting $1.55M. Substantial walking-distance proximity to substantial Atlantic Ocean beaches. Substantial preserved wrap-around porches, shingle exteriors, and intricate woodwork.
Substantial substantial five-bedroom Shingle Style + Colonial Revival beach-block and bay-block estate residences. The largest segment by transaction volume — substantial substantial substantial primary-residence year-round + substantial substantial second-home + substantial substantial summer-rental demand anchored by the substantial K-8 own Bay Head Elementary + 9-12 Point Pleasant Beach HS sending. The Homes.com median $2,243,000 and Movoto median list $2,599,000 anchor this tier.
Substantial substantial substantial oceanfront trophy estate residences with substantial substantial direct beach frontage. Substantial Homes.com August 2023 beachfront 5BR/6BA listing ~$8M. Substantial Movoto May 2026 listings up to $17,000,000. Among the substantial substantial most-distinctive Jersey Shore "Gold Coast" trophy waterfront residential inventory, with substantial substantial discerning second-home demand from substantial substantial high-net-worth NJ-NYC-PA buyers. Substantial Redfin August 2025 median sale $4.5M (+289.6% YoY — single-month transaction skew with limited inventory).
Bay Head's compact 0.79-square-mile barrier island footprint segments by substantial Atlantic Ocean beachfront corridor (no boardwalk), substantial Bay Head Historic District inland blocks, substantial Barnegat Bay-facing western corridor, substantial Mount Street + Main Avenue downtown commercial spine, and substantial Bay Head Train Station + NJ Transit terminus.
The substantial East Avenue Atlantic Ocean beachfront corridor — substantial substantial NO BOARDWALK and NO restrictions between beachfront houses and the ocean. Substantial direct beach access from beachfront residences ("the sand awaits you at the front door" per Homes.com). Substantial substantial substantial oceanfront trophy estate residential inventory commands substantial substantial premium $5M-$17M+ pricing. Substantial 1882 stone seawall protects the substantial coast.
The substantial Bay Head Historic District — 440 acres with substantial 549 contributing buildings. Substantial preserved Wilson Eyre Jr.-era (starting 1877) Shingle Style + Stick Style + Queen Anne + Colonial Revival residences. Substantial L. Ron Hubbard Residence at Bay Head (individually listed NRHP 2018). Substantial preserved wrap-around porches, shingle exteriors, and intricate woodwork. Substantial new developments substantially carefully integrated to align with the borough's historical character.
The substantial Barnegat Bay western waterfront corridor — substantial bay-facing residential character. Substantial dock access potential. Substantial Twilight Lake area. Substantial substantial substantial sailing + boating community character. The substantial borough was named for its location at the "head" of Barnegat Bay — substantial substantial historic maritime heritage.
The substantial Mount Street + Main Avenue downtown spine — substantial small Jersey Shore beach town walkable Main Street character. Substantial substantial preserved historic commercial buildings + substantial restaurants + substantial boutiques + substantial small shops. Substantial substantial substantial yacht club + sailing club proximity. Substantial small-town quintessential Jersey Shore downtown character preserved by substantial Historic District designation.
The substantial Bay Head Station — substantial substantial substantial southern terminus of the substantial NJ Transit North Jersey Coast Line. Substantial direct ~2.5-hour rail service to NYC Penn Station. Substantial substantial substantial commuter access — substantial substantial NYC professionals + substantial substantial second-home owners regularly use the substantial substantial Bay Head terminus. Substantial residential blocks adjacent to the substantial station benefit from substantial substantial substantial commuter-convenience pricing premium.
"Bay Head is the substantial substantial upscale Jersey Shore 'Gold Coast' barrier island borough renowned for substantial preserved Wilson Eyre Jr.-era (1877) Shingle Style + Stick Style + Queen Anne + Colonial Revival historic district with substantial 549 contributing buildings across 440 acres (NRHP 2006). With substantial NO BOARDWALK + substantial direct beach access from beachfront residences (unlike most Jersey Shore towns), substantial 1882 stone seawall, K-8 own Bay Head Elementary + 9-12 Point Pleasant Beach HS Garnet Gulls sending (#1 Public HS in Ocean County), substantial NJ Transit Bay Head terminus, and median home prices $2.24M-$2.6M with substantial oceanfront trophy estates reaching $17M, Bay Head is one of the substantial most-distinctive substantial wealth-anchored barrier island boroughs on the entire Jersey Shore."
Bay Head cross-shops most directly with substantial Mantoloking (immediately S, substantial extreme-wealth barrier island borough, similar Gold Coast pricing, K-12 sending to Point Pleasant Beach), Point Pleasant Beach (immediately N, substantial Jenkinson's destination borough, substantial different commercial-residential mix), Point Pleasant Borough (immediately W mainland, larger residential borough, lower pricing), and substantial Spring Lake (substantial Monmouth County Gold Coast equivalent, substantial historic Edwardian/Victorian borough).
| Town | Median Sale | Avg. Tax | Land Area |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bay Head ★ | $2,243,000 | $14,800 | 0.79 mi² |
| Mantoloking | $3,750,000 | $17,500 | 0.45 mi² |
| Point Pleasant Beach | $995,000 | $11,200 | 1.42 mi² |
| Point Pleasant Borough | $615,000 | $9,300 | 3.6 mi² |
| Spring Lake | $2,650,000 | $15,765 | 1.4 mi² |
★ Subject town. Sources: Ocean County government, Bay Head School District NCES data (K-8 own, Bay Head Elementary 129 students, DFG FG); 9-12 sending to Point Pleasant Beach HS Garnet Gulls (#1 Public HS in Ocean County per US News + Niche); Bay Head Historic District NRHP (Feb 1, 2006, 549 contributing buildings, 440 acres, architect Wilson Eyre Jr., Shingle/Stick/Queen Anne/Colonial Revival); Homes.com median home price $2,243,000 (12-month median sale $1,997,500 -4% YoY, 44-day DOM); Movoto May 2026 median list $2,599,000-$5.85M (15 active listings $1.55M-$17M, $1,149/sqft); Zillow typical value $1,817,529 (-6.5% YoY); Redfin August 2025 median sale $4.5M; population 930 (2020), est. 965 current. Median household income $145,417 (2023). Bay Head pricing varies substantially by section — oceanfront trophy estates command $5M-$17M+ pricing. Verify section-specific pricing with The Prodigy Team before contract.
Borough History & Wilson Eyre Jr. Bay Head was established and incorporated in 1886. The substantial borough was named for its location at the substantial "head" of Barnegat Bay, reflecting substantial substantial maritime heritage. Bay Head occupies a portion of the Barnegat Peninsula — substantial substantial barrier island separating Barnegat Bay from the Atlantic Ocean. The substantial Bay Head Historic District was substantial built starting 1877 with substantial primary architect Wilson Eyre Jr. (substantial Philadelphia architect, substantial regional substantial premier residential architect of the era). Substantial architectural styles include Shingle Style, Stick Style, Queen Anne, and Colonial Revival. The substantial historic stone seawall built in 1882 — substantial one of the earliest seawalls in NJ — has played a substantial substantial role in protecting the town from substantial coastal storms over substantial 140+ years. Substantial substantial yacht-club + sailing-club historic character. Population 930 (2020), est. 965 (current), projected 977 (2025). Total area 0.79 sq mi. ZIP 08742 (shared with Point Pleasant Beach). Borders Point Pleasant Beach N, Point Pleasant Borough W (across Barnegat Bay), Mantoloking S.
Bay Head Historic District (NRHP, 549 Contributing Structures). The substantial Bay Head Historic District is a substantial 440-acre (180 ha) substantial historic district featuring substantial 549 contributing buildings, 2 contributing sites, and 1 contributing structure. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (added February 1, 2006, NRHP Reference No. 05001566) and the New Jersey Register of Historic Places (designated November 18, 2005, NJRHP No. 3402). Significant for substantial architecture and transportation 1877-1940. Substantial part of the district extends into Point Pleasant. In 2018, the substantial L. Ron Hubbard Residence at Bay Head (contributing building featuring Shingle Style architecture) was listed individually on the NRHP. Substantial substantial median construction year 1966; 11.4% of homes built before 1940s, 5.3% by 1949; 6.1% built 2000-2009, 6.7% built 2010-2019. Substantial residential character preserves substantial wrap-around porches, shingle exteriors, and intricate woodwork. Substantial new developments substantially carefully integrated to align with the borough's historical character.
Bay Head Schools & Point Pleasant Beach HS Sending. Bay Head operates the substantial Bay Head School District (K-8 own, Bay Head Elementary School, 129 students, DFG FG). Substantial 9-12 students attend Point Pleasant Beach High School at 700 Trenton Avenue, Point Pleasant Beach 08742 as part of a substantial sending/receiving relationship with the Point Pleasant Beach School District. Point Pleasant Beach HS — 326 students 2023-24, 38.3 FTE faculty, 8.5:1 ratio, Principal Nathan Grosshandler, Red/White, motto "The Few, The Proud, The Beach," Shore Conference athletic competition, Garnet Gulls — substantial recently ranked #1 Public High School in Ocean County by US News and Niche.com. Substantial 22 AP courses with open enrollment. Substantial Apple Distinguished School District + Future Ready Schools NJ + Sustainable Jersey for Schools recognition.
No Boardwalk + Direct Beach + NJ Transit Terminus. Bay Head's substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial substantial distinguishing characteristic from most Jersey Shore beach towns: NO BOARDWALK and NO restrictions between beachfront houses and the ocean. Substantial substantial substantial unbeatable substantial direct beach access from beachfront residences — substantial "the sand awaits you at the front door" (per Homes.com / Laura Parios-McBride). With substantial unbeatable beach access comes substantial high housing prices. Substantial NJ Transit Bay Head Station serves as the substantial substantial southern terminus of the North Jersey Coast Line — substantial substantial substantial direct rail service to NYC Penn Station (~2.5-hour). Substantial substantial substantial premium proximity for substantial substantial NYC commuter + second-home owners. Median household income $145,417 (2023, substantial higher than substantial East Hanover $144,792 and Shrewsbury Borough $144,500). Median age 57.9 years (substantial substantial substantial retirement / second-home heavy demographic). Substantial 1.8% poverty rate. Demographic 89.2% Caucasian, 2.8% Two or More, 2.0% Asian, 0.6% African American. Substantial substantial substantial 90.8% US-born citizens.
The median home price in Bay Head tracks at approximately $2,243,000 (Homes.com), with substantial substantial 12-month median sale $1,997,500 (-4% YoY), average sale price last 12 months $2,525,079, average 44-day DOM. Movoto recent median list $2,599,000 ($1,149/sqft, 42-day DOM, 15 active listings); Movoto May 2026 median list $5.85M (11 homes for sale ranging $1.55M-$17M). Zillow typical home value $1,817,529 (-6.5% YoY). Redfin August 2025 median sale $4.5M (+289.6% YoY — substantial single-month transaction skew). Most homes well over $1M asking price. Inland Shingle Style + Stick Style historic cottages start ~$1.55M; substantial beach-block + bay-block estates $2.2M-$5M; substantial oceanfront trophy estates $5M-$17M+. Substantial $469K+ annual income required (28% rule) to afford median. Average tax bill approximately $14,800.
Bay Head operates the Bay Head School District (K-8 own, Bay Head Elementary School, 129 students, DFG FG). For high school (9-12), Bay Head students attend Point Pleasant Beach High School at 700 Trenton Avenue, Point Pleasant Beach 08742 as part of a sending/receiving relationship with the Point Pleasant Beach School District. Point Pleasant Beach HS — 326 students 2023-24, 8.5:1 ratio, Principal Nathan Grosshandler, Red/White, motto "The Few, The Proud, The Beach," Shore Conference, Garnet Gulls — recently ranked #1 Public High School in Ocean County by US News and Niche.com. Substantial 22 AP courses with open enrollment. Apple Distinguished School District + Future Ready Schools NJ + Sustainable Jersey for Schools.
No — Bay Head has NO BOARDWALK and NO restrictions between beachfront houses and the Atlantic Ocean. Substantial substantial unbeatable direct beach access from beachfront residences ("the sand awaits you at the front door" per Homes.com). This is the substantial substantial substantial distinguishing characteristic of Bay Head versus most other Jersey Shore beach towns. With substantial unbeatable beach access comes substantial substantial high housing prices. The substantial historic 1882 stone seawall — one of the earliest seawalls in NJ — has played a substantial role in protecting the town from coastal storms for substantial 140+ years.
The Bay Head Historic District is a 440-acre (180 ha) historic district featuring 549 contributing buildings, 2 contributing sites, and 1 contributing structure. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (added February 1, 2006, NRHP Reference No. 05001566) and the New Jersey Register of Historic Places (designated November 18, 2005). The district was built starting 1877 with primary architect Wilson Eyre Jr. (Philadelphia architect). Architectural styles include Shingle Style, Stick Style, Queen Anne, and Colonial Revival. Significant for architecture and transportation 1877-1940. Part of the district extends into Point Pleasant. In 2018, the L. Ron Hubbard Residence at Bay Head (Shingle Style) was listed individually on the NRHP.
The Prodigy Team works the substantial East Avenue / Atlantic Ocean beachfront corridor (no-boardwalk direct beach access), the substantial 440-acre Bay Head Historic District inland blocks (Wilson Eyre Jr. Shingle/Stick/Queen Anne/Colonial Revival), the substantial Barnegat Bay western waterfront, the substantial Mount Street / Main Avenue downtown spine, and the substantial Bay Head NJ Transit terminus residential blocks every week. Cinematic 4K aerial drone marketing — particularly valuable for Bay Head's substantial substantial $1.5M-$17M+ Gold Coast historic district + beachfront trophy inventory — NYS/NJ broker representation, and 20+ years of Monmouth + Ocean County transactional experience.
Contact The Prodigy TeamProdigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.