Anthony Licciardello | November 22, 2026
Rahway, NJ
Union County · Sales Ledger · Fall 2026 · Rahway, NJ
Seventy-one closings since August, a top sale of $900,000, and a house from 1840 that sold in three weeks. Here is what sold in Rahway, how old each property was, and how much floor area the money bought.
Rahway has what most of its neighbors charge extra for: a train station on the Northeast Corridor, a downtown with an arts district, and a river park. It also has prices well below the towns to its west. Our Union County commuter guide covers the train. This ledger covers what the houses sold for.
Between August 1 and November 20, 2026, the Garden State MLS feeds recorded 71 closed sales at Rahway addresses, worth about $39.2 million combined. Ten closed at $700,000 or more. Forty-seven closed at $500,000 or more. Twelve closed below $450,000. The middle sale of the 71 was $530,000.
The highest sale of the period closed on August 7. Eighteen-oh-four Rutherford Street, a four-bedroom, four-bath home with 2,600 square feet, sold for $900,000 after nine days on the market. That is about $346 a square foot.
Second was 417 Linden Avenue, a 1968 property with eight bedrooms and four baths, at $880,000 on August 6. Third was 555 Jackson Avenue, built in 1963 with 2,400 square feet, at $803,000. Fourth was 1004 Jaques Avenue, built in 1905, at $790,000.
Five of the ten were listed without a bedroom count, which in these feeds usually points to a two-family or multi-family property. That fits Rahway, where older two-family houses near downtown and the station are a large part of the upper price range. The single-family sales in the group include a 1981 home at 507 Stalevicz Lane at $765,000 and a 2020 home at 102 East Emerson Avenue at $722,000.
All closings 2026. Bd / Ba is bedrooms and baths; a dash means the listing was published without a count. Built is the year in MLS or tax records. Square footage is the listing figure where one was published.
Six properties on this list carry the same build year, 1930. They sold from $525,000 to $745,000.
The low end is a three-bedroom, two-bath house on Wilson Avenue at $525,000. The high end is 139 Coddington Street, with 3,611 square feet on record, at $745,000. Size explains most of the gap: Coddington Street sold for only $206 a square foot, the lowest figure on the tape.
The 1952 pair is a matter of size: a two-bedroom, one-bath on Apgar Terrace at $400,000 and a four-bedroom, two-bath on Maurice Avenue at $530,000. The 2020 pair is the closest of the three. A four-bedroom on Hulick Place sold for $680,000 in eight days and a three-bedroom, three-bath on East Emerson Avenue for $722,000. New houses in Rahway sell in a narrow band. Older ones spread out according to size and condition.
Forty-six of the 71 sales have a build year on record. Twelve of those properties predate 1940. Twenty-three date from 1942 to 1968. Five are from 1981 to 1999, and six were built since 2007.
The oldest is a house at 173 Monroe Street with a build year of 1840 on record. It has three bedrooms, three baths and 1,190 square feet, and it sold for $560,000 in 22 days, or $471 a foot. That was the second-highest price per foot on the whole list. A 1905 property on Jaques Avenue and a 1922 property at 355 West Scott Avenue both sold at $750,000 or more.
The postwar houses are the core of the market. The 23 sales from 1942 to 1968 ran from $385,000 to $880,000, and most closed between $450,000 and $680,000. The six newest properties include three condominiums at Carriage City Plaza and the two 2020 houses.
Counts cover the 46 closings in this ledger with a build year in MLS or tax records.
Rahway listings are published with a square footage more often than those in the towns around it. Twenty-six of the 71 sales have one, and the price per foot runs from $206 to $488.
The range is tighter than those numbers suggest. Twenty-two of the 26 sold between $335 and $471 a foot. The top figure is Stalevicz Lane at $488, followed by the 1840 house on Monroe Street at $471 and a 1952 house of 1,124 square feet at 2339 Knapp Drive at $463.
The three lowest figures all belong to larger properties: Coddington Street at $206 with 3,611 square feet, a 1950 home at 883 Milton Boulevard at $237 with 1,984, and 1030 Westfield Avenue at $285 with 1,792. The three Carriage City Plaza condominiums sold between $363 and $379 a foot.
Dark bars are sales above $400 a foot. Each figure is the closed price divided by the square footage published with the listing.
A two-family house and a single-family house are not priced the same way, even when the square footage matches. Several of the largest figures on this tape belong to properties listed without a bedroom count, which usually means more than one unit. Before you compare two Rahway properties by price per foot, confirm that both are the same type and that both numbers measure finished living space.
Six properties built in 1930 sold as much as $220,000 apart this fall. We will line your home up against the closings that actually match it, and tell you what it is worth as it stands.
The fastest sale was a 1965 four-bedroom at 362 Washington Street, which sold for $625,000 in three days. Hulick Place and a 1957 home at 895 Apgar Terrace each sold in eight, and the top sale on Rutherford Street in nine.
Four sales took more than 100 days. A three-bedroom at 265 East Stearns Street took 153 days and closed at $485,000. A 1950 home at 1103 Elm Terrace took 150 and closed at $455,000. Homes on Briarcliff Drive and Leesville Avenue took 110 and 108. All four closed below $555,000, in the part of the market where buyers have the most choice.
The condominium tower at 1 Carriage City Plaza, next to the station, had three two-bedroom, two-bath sales: $427,000, $449,000 and $450,000, for units of 1,126 to 1,236 square feet. The lowest closing of the period was $305,000 for a three-bedroom at 398 Harrison Street.
Closings under $700,000 with a build year or square footage on record. Days is days on market as reported with the closed listing. Nineteen more closings had neither on record; they are counted in the totals and not shown as cards.
If you own a two-family house in Rahway, do not price it from single-family sales, and do not let a buyer do that either. A two-family is valued on its rents as well as its size, and several of the top ten sales this fall were listed the way multi-family properties are. Bring your leases and your rent roll to the pricing conversation.
"Rahway is one of the few places left in Union County where you can still buy a house near a Northeast Corridor station for around half a million dollars. The buyers know it. The homes that were priced right this fall sold in under two weeks, and the ones that sat for five months were the ones that were not."
Buyers leaving New York for a direct train to Penn Station at a price they can carry often put Rahway on the list early. The Prodigy Team is licensed on both sides of the bridge, so we work with those buyers before they ever tour a New Jersey home. Our digital reach is built for that pipeline: a YouTube channel with more than 400,000 views over the past year, a relocation community of more than 26,500 members on Facebook, and more than 17 million impressions on Pinterest.
Our in-house aerial series, Above the Streets, shows a home in the context buyers care about: the lot, the block and the town around it.
Call 718-873-7345 or start with a home value review.
1804 Rutherford Street, which closed on August 7, 2026 at $900,000 after nine days on the market. It has four bedrooms, four baths and 2,600 square feet.
The middle sale of the 71 closings between August 1 and November 20, 2026 was $530,000. Forty-seven closed at $500,000 or more and ten at $700,000 or more. None reached $1 million.
Of 46 closings in this ledger with a build year on record, 12 were built before 1940, 23 between 1942 and 1968, five between 1981 and 1999, and six since 2007. The oldest carried a build year of 1840.
Among the 26 closings with a published square footage, the range ran from $206 to $488 per square foot, and 22 of the 26 sold between $335 and $471.
Three two-bedroom units at 1 Carriage City Plaza, built in 2008, sold between $427,000 and $450,000 this period. A two-bedroom at 1470 Campbell Street sold for $395,000.
Sources and data notes. Closed sale prices and dates: Garden State Multiple Listing Service closed-sale records as displayed by Movoto and Homes.com, retrieved November 21, 2026, covering 71 closings at Rahway addresses from August 1 through November 20, 2026. Build years, bedroom and bath counts, days on market and listing square footage: GSMLS listing records as displayed by Homes.com and participating IDX sites. Price-per-square-foot figures are the closed price divided by the square footage shown. Totals and counts are calculated from this ledger and describe these 71 closings only; they are not a town-wide median. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.