Anthony Licciardello | November 22, 2026
Mountainside, NJ
Union County · Sales Ledger · Fall 2026 · Mountainside, NJ
Thirty closings since August, half of them at $1 million or more, and not one below $600,000. Here is what sold in Mountainside, how old each house was, and how much floor area the money bought.
Mountainside is small, and it sells few houses. The borough sits between Route 22 and the Watchung Reservation, has no downtown train station, and is made up mostly of single-family homes on wide lots. Thirty of them changed hands this fall. Current listings are on our Mountainside homes for sale page.
Between August 1 and November 20, 2026, the Garden State MLS feeds recorded 30 closed sales at Mountainside addresses, worth about $33.9 million combined. Fifteen closed at $1 million or more, and seven of those above $1.5 million. Eleven closed between $800,000 and $1 million. Four closed below $800,000.
The highest sale of the period closed on September 22. Ten twenty-three Prospect Avenue, a four-bedroom, three-bath home built in 1962, sold for $1,814,000. Second was 244 Pembrook Road, built in 1953, with four bedrooms and five baths, at $1,746,000 on August 17.
Five more homes closed above $1.5 million. A five-bedroom at 1445 Deer Path sold for $1,658,000 on November 10. Two newer homes closed on the same day, September 18: 301 Garrett Road, built in 2017, at $1,655,000, and 1233 Poplar Avenue, built in 2015, at $1,650,000. Poplar Avenue sold in four days. Garrett Road took 69.
The last two are 1950s houses. A 1950 home at 1531 Coles Avenue, with five bedrooms, five baths and 6,579 square feet on record, sold for $1,545,000. A 1955 home at 1003 Charles Street, with four bedrooms and four baths, sold for $1,527,500. All 15 sales at $1 million and above are below.
All closings 2026. Bd / Ba is bedrooms and baths. Built is the year in MLS or tax records. Square footage is the listing figure where one was published. A dash means the figure was not published.
Most Mountainside homes were built within a few years of each other, which makes the tape a good test of how much the build year matters. The answer is not much.
Two houses on this list were built in 1955. A four-bedroom, two-bath home on Mill Lane sold for $790,000. A four-bedroom, four-bath home on Charles Street sold for $1,527,500. Two were built in 1962: a three-bedroom on Brookside Road sold for $1,100,000 in seven days, and the four-bedroom on Prospect Avenue was the top sale in town.
The 1952 pair shows the same thing on a smaller scale. A three-bedroom, two-bath home on Birch Hill Road sold for $850,000, and a four-bedroom, four-bath home on Dunn Parkway for $1,125,000. In all three pairs, the higher price went to the house with more baths. In a borough of 1950s ranches and split-levels, the homes that have been expanded and updated sell in a different bracket from the ones that have not.
Twenty of the 30 sales have a build year on record. Ten of those homes were built in the 1950s. Sixteen date from 1947 to 1970. Only four fall outside that span: a 1930 house, a 1980 house, and two built in 2015 and 2017.
The ten homes from the 1950s sold from $790,000 to $1,746,000, a spread of nearly a million dollars inside a single decade. The oldest house on the list, built in 1930 at 291 Central Avenue, sold for $635,000 after 53 days. The two newest were both among the top five sales.
Counts cover the 20 closings in this ledger with a build year in MLS or tax records.
Square footage is thin in the Mountainside records. Only four of the 30 sales were published with a figure that can be used, so this section is a short one.
The smallest of the four, a 1947 house of 1,693 square feet at 240 Summit Road, sold for $855,000, or $505 a foot. The other three are much larger and sold for much less per foot: 486 Summit Road, built in 1980 with 2,782 square feet, at $324; 1179 Blazo Terrace, with 3,444 square feet, at $315; and Coles Avenue, with 6,579 square feet on record, at $235.
Each figure is the closed price divided by the square footage published with the listing.
Four sales are not enough to set a price per foot for Mountainside, and the largest figure here almost certainly includes finished lower-level space. Many homes in the borough are ranches and split-levels built into a slope, where a walk-out lower level may or may not be counted. Before you compare two homes by price per foot, find out what each number includes.
Two houses built in 1955 sold $737,500 apart this fall. We will line your home up against the closings that actually match it, and tell you what it is worth as it stands.
The fastest sale was Poplar Avenue, at four days. Brookside Road sold in seven, and a 1966 home at 350 Greenbrier Court sold in twelve at $901,000. Most of the rest took between 19 and 33 days.
Seven sales took 53 days or longer, and they were spread across the price range: a three-bedroom at 587 Woodland Avenue at $600,000 after 71 days, Garrett Road at $1,655,000 after 69, and a 1969 home at 1080 Prospect Avenue at $999,999 after 68. In a borough with this few sales, one house that waits for its buyer does not mean the market has slowed.
Closings under $1,000,000. Days is days on market as reported with the closed listing. A dash means the figure was not published.
If you own an original 1950s ranch or split-level in Mountainside, count the bathrooms before you look at comparable sales. In all three same-year pairs on this list, the house with more baths sold for $275,000 to $737,500 more. A buyer at $1.5 million expects a primary suite and a bath for every bedroom wing. If your house has two baths, compare it with the two-bath sales.
"Mountainside only sold thirty houses this fall, so every one of them counts as a comparable. Half went for more than a million dollars and nothing sold under six hundred thousand. If you are pricing a house here, there is no room for a guess. The sales on your side of the borough are few enough to read one by one."
Buyers leaving New York for a quiet street and a wide lot often start in the rail towns and then find Mountainside a few minutes up the hill. The Prodigy Team is licensed on both sides of the bridge, so we work with those buyers before they ever tour a New Jersey home. Our digital reach is built for that pipeline: a YouTube channel with more than 400,000 views over the past year, a relocation community of more than 26,500 members on Facebook, and more than 17 million impressions on Pinterest.
Our in-house aerial series, Above the Streets, shows a home in the context buyers care about: the lot, the block and the town around it.
Call 718-873-7345 or start with a home value review.
1023 Prospect Avenue, which closed on September 22, 2026 at $1,814,000. It was built in 1962 and has four bedrooms and three baths.
Fifteen of the 30 closings between August 1 and November 20, 2026, at prices from $1,085,000 to $1,814,000. Seven closed above $1.5 million.
Of 20 closings in this ledger with a build year on record, 10 were built in the 1950s and 16 between 1947 and 1970. The oldest dated from 1930 and the newest from 2017.
$600,000, for a three-bedroom home at 587 Woodland Avenue that closed on October 6, 2026. Only four of the 30 sales closed below $800,000.
The fastest sale in this ledger took four days and the slowest 71. Most homes with a reported figure sold in 19 to 33 days.
Sources and data notes. Closed sale prices and dates: Garden State Multiple Listing Service closed-sale records as displayed by Movoto and Homes.com, retrieved November 21, 2026, covering 30 closings at Mountainside addresses from August 1 through November 20, 2026. Build years, bedroom and bath counts, days on market and listing square footage: GSMLS listing records as displayed by Homes.com and participating IDX sites. Price-per-square-foot figures are the closed price divided by the square footage shown. Totals and counts are calculated from this ledger and describe these 30 closings only; they are not a town-wide median. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Prodigy Real Estate is an innovative real estate company offering high-end video production, home valuation services, purchasing, and home sales. Serving New York and New Jersey.